Peacemaker Lobster & Crab

$ $ $
1831 Sidney Street, St Louis, Mo, 63104
St Louis, MO


  • The Brisket Po Boy is our of this world! You can in/out for lunch in 39 minutes.
  • Food and service are great. Can attest to the Maine Lobster roll and Shrimp Poboy. The "corn dogs" (it's full-sized and there's only one) and hush puppies share a batter and are also tasty.
  • The decor and ambience is a cross between Restoration Hardware and a Ralph Lauren outlet store. Food is decent and the beer selection is interesting. Knowing Sidney Street Cafe, give it some time
  • Try the lobster roll: generous pieces of whole Maine lobster -- claws, tail, knuckles -- are lightly tossed with mayonnaise and lemon zest.
  • To say that Peacemaker Lobster & Crab Co. brings good seafood to St. Louis is a huge understatement.
  • Connecticut Roll and Peacemaker Po' Boy are both incredible! Great atmosphere as well!
  • Great fresh seafood, which is pricey but worth it. The lobster boil and lobster rolls are delicious, and would definitely come back to try the rest of the menu.
  • Smoked brisket, and the clams. Their horseradish sauce is excellent.
  • We ordered the shrimp po boy and crab roll. Both were super tasty! I'm also a fan of the bourbon slushee!!
  • Whoa!! Top 10 on my list. Incredible food. Amazing services. At one point I thought we had 13 wait staff caring for every want and desire we had. Awesome experience. Totally recommend this place!
  • Lobster roll or Crab roll...enjoy! Bon petit.
  • Awesome seafood. Sooo fresh!
  • This place is really, really tasty but the market price of lobster in St. Louis can be staggering.
  • Makes me feel like I'm back on the east coast.
  • Lobster roll
  • We went the poor boys, sides and soup and didn't break the bank and it was very good!
  • Unreal lobster rolls
  • Probably the best (only?) place in St. Louis to get a lobster roll. Definitely not a normal item in this landlocked city. Be warned though sandwich is on the smaller side, and not cheap.
  • The lobster roll might be pricey but it's worth it! Some of the best hush puppies too.
  • Great peel and eat shrimp and gumbo at lunch. Great atmosphere too.

Nearby places

2256 S 39th St (Shenandoah)
1818 Sidney St (Lemp Ave. and Sidney St.)
6726 Chippewa St (at Prather Ave)