Paulie Gee's

Row 1

2451 N Milwaukee Ave (Sacramento Ave)
Chicago, IL 60647
(773) 360-1072
Mon, Wed–Thu: 5:30 PM–10:00 PM Fri: 5:30 PM–2:00 AM Sat: 5:00 PM–2:00 AM Sun: 5:00 PM–10:00 PM

Foursquare Tips

  • Best Neapolitan style pizza in Chicago hands down. And the Detroit style just sideswiped me with unexpected deliciousness.
  • Detroit pie. The crust is incredible.
  • The crust on the Detroit inspired pizzas is SO delicious. It's airy, crispy, and crunchy.
  • Food is great. The service a little lacking
  • Naples inspired pizza done right. My veggie friends love it. I love it. The fennel sausage is to die for. Proper cocktails. Great beer. Friendly owner. Just do it!
  • Absurdly friendly staff and great wood fired pizza. But their squares are a secret treat!
  • Ask for the secret menu and order the bacon and eggs!
  • Derrick Tung created a menu category just for the Chicago location: Logan Squares, referring to (oddly enough) Detroit-style rectangular pan pizza.
  • Originated in Brooklyn, this pizza shop offers some delicious pies and beverages in an open feeling space. Late night menu served until 2am means you have a new fourth-meal option in Logan Square.
  • If you like your pizza a little bit sweet, you'll love Pauly Gee's.
  • The Hellboy Pizza will change your life! It is by far the best pizza I have ever had.
  • Great pizza and very friendly staff. Night I was there, owner/co-owner was introducing himself and checking in on tables. Super chill.
  • It doesn't get better than the sopresata on the hellboy
  • Great pizza for sure but the secret is that the cocktails are amazeballs.
  • We had the Porkypineapple and Cherry Jones - both were amazing!
  • Worst pizza ever... Plain and expensive.