Out of the Fire Cafe

Row 1

3782 State Route 31
Donegal, PA 15628
(724) 593-4200
Steakhouse, American
$ $ $ $
Wed–Thu, Sun: 11:00 AM–8:00 PM Fri–Sat: 11:00 AM–9:00 PM

Foursquare Tips

  • A yummy BYOB near Falling Water, their specialty is smoked salmon, and we recommend any of the risotto's on the menu.
  • Just come to Out of the Fire....your tastebuds will thank you! Bring your own wine or beer!
  • Hard to go wrong with any meal here! Smoked salmon, seafood and steaks all very good.
  • Their tuna tacos are amazing!
  • Food was delicious...one of the best burgers I've ever eaten. Mushroom soup was terrific.
  • BYOB. Salmon macaroni & cheese is divine, a must try. Beware, starters are almost as big as the entrees, but any leftovers can be packed. Always check out specials. Food quality is great here.
  • Their signature mushroom soup is to die for!!!
  • Food and service are 4 Star
  • Great Mushroom soup( if not spicy) good sandwiches,. Good service, waiters wear uniforms, nice touch. Past year food is too spicy/too heavy on pepper for general public.
  • The New York strip steak was excellent
  • Really enjoyed the special with a duck egg on top!
  • Terrific Margherita pizza. Dough was crunch and chewy - tomatoes, mozzarella and basil all fresh and delicious. I will remember this place and come back next time I am in Pittsburgh!
  • Pricey, but delicious high end seafood with a scenic view of the Pennsylvania hills. Warning: it's BYOB!
  • Bananas foster was excellent, perfect size to split w/hubby.
  • Great "BLT's"... Yumm ! Drove up from Mt Lebanon just to buy 3 qts of mushroom soup for a dinner party!
  • Try the ribeye, which is cold smoked for five hours. They recommend getting it medium well.
  • This restaurant is phenomenal. Worth the trip from Pittsburgh. BYOB. The mushroom soup is awesome. The Filet amazing. This place is great. Go. Now.
  • The Mac and cheese is always the best !!
  • Staying at 7Springs or Hidden Valley for the weekend? Come to OOTF for an amazing meal that I wish I could get in the City. BYOB. Definitely make reservations.
  • Exquisite service, amazing, well made seafood. My 2 year old devoured the mac and cheese!