Johnny's Italian Steakhouse

Row 1

8390 Market St
Middleton, WI 53562
(608) 831-3705
$ $ $
Mon–Thu, Sun: 11:00 AM–9:00 PM Fri–Sat: 11:00 AM–10:00 PM

Foursquare Tips

  • NY Strip is very good.
  • Trio...steak (butter knife tender), fettuccine and chicken parm...we'll worth it!
  • Steak entrees are big and come with salad.
  • Try the Drunken Steak, it's delicious! If you want to go a step further upgrade to filet mignon for an even better dish!
  • So-so food, waitstaff that is more interested in socializing with their friends then helping their customers, and being surrounded by loud, profane patrons are just the tip of the iceberg. Not again.
  • If you don't get the iron skillet potatoes you didn't really eat here. Must get them!
  • Chef Rod is amazing! Very friendly!
  • Call ahead to make a reservation! It's the first step towards a relaxing dining experience.
  • Great food, nice atmosphere, decently priced. Very enjoyable. Will return.
  • I had the Chicken Madeira. Was really good. Loved that you got lots of salad for dinner. And any refills. As well as bread!
  • Steaks & martinis
  • Get the parmesan encrusted New York strip.
  • The Sunday brunch here is an awesome deal!
  • Best old fashioned in town
  • $5 take out menu for lunch!
  • The parmesan steak is amazing.
  • Second chances are just that...chances. we shall see...
  • Justin is the best waiter ever...
  • If you can put up with indifference of the staff the food is worth it
  • Ordered seafood skewers. The waitress was not personable. No name, didn't ask if we had questions, etc. The food was good but the seafood skewers should be called vegetable skews. 1 shrimp 1 scallop.