Dave's Grill

Row 1

468 W Lake Dr
Montauk, NY 11954
(631) 668-9190
$ $ $ $
Mon–Thu, Sun: 5:00 PM–11:00 PM Fri–Sat: 5:00 PM–Midnight

Foursquare Tips

  • One of the toughest tables to get in Montauk. In-the-know diners start dialing at 4:15 p.m.when the reservation line opensto sample hearty cioppino and onion-and-potato-crusted flounder.
  • The hostess is lovely
  • Tough table to get in montauk during the summer. Good food. Friendly staff
  • Baked stuffed lobster and spare ribs app are off the charts.
  • tuna spread is lovely. portions are hearty, so opt for 2 courses only if really hungry
  • Not easy to get a reservation but not sure why. Good restaurant but not great at all. Give it a try on an off night but not worth a wait. Fudge Sunday was the best thing we had
  • Excellent dinner, relaxing atmosphere. Don't count on a reservation unless you are a member of the club. The staff is terrific. The crab cakes served at our table were said to be superb. Zagat = 27
  • The poached lobster is a SUPER rich lobster role, and required an empty stomach. The lobster pappardelle appie is a delicious meal on it's own.
  • amazing. everything.
  • We had a pretty good meal, my only situation was when my teenager felt her swordfish was off, the waitress was not interested in exchanging it. The waitress recommended it to boot!
  • The tuna spread is amazing!
  • Simply the best no matter what you get!
  • I will speak up for the potato-and-onion crusted flounder. It's easily the best rendition of fish-and-chips you will find this side of the Atlantic. The Cukito cocktail is also lovely.
  • Stuffed lobster is a winner!
  • Best crab cake I've ever had in my life. Get the regular Barbara for dessert, not the mini one!
  • Everything is delicious
  • Ciopinno and the sometimes surf and turf peppered sherry steak with the butter poached lobster, amazing!!!!!!! Best I've ever tasted!