Captain Carlo's Fish Market
Map: Surroundings & Nearby
Ligas U2 cover band
Had a bowl of the Lobster Bisque, the Blue Point oysters, and the fried scallops. Everything was on point and delicious.
Check out their website It's a little hoaky but you can still see all of their tasty treats and link to their whale watching tours website too.
Make sure to get a lobster roll and fried clams. Both are killer good.