Anderson's Frozen Custard

Row 1

2235 Sheridan Dr (at Logan Ave)
Tonawanda, NY 14223
(716) 875-5952
Ice Cream, Sandwiches
Mon–Thu, Sun: 11:00 AM–9:00 PM Fri–Sat: 11:00 AM–10:00 PM

Foursquare Tips

  • Go for the Beef On Weck.
  • Get some lemon ice. It's cool and refreshing.
  • It is all about the custard here. Small is the perfect treat leaving you wanting more. No need to choose between chocolate and vanilla have the twist!
  • Best fricken banana splits in the world.
  • The original location of a Buffalo classic since 1946. Try the famous roast beef, custard or lemon ice. There's always a special custard flavor, and it's half-price cones when it's snowing.
  • Love watching people use the door when the garage doors are open.
  • Carl's Choice on Weck, plus a lemon ice can not be beat.
  • Had a great malt shake here last week, tasty frozen drinks and such:)
  • Good place for local eats. Excellent variety of hard and soft ice cream with flavors of the day. Where else can you get a good burger or roast beef sandwich and a peanut butter chunk cone for dessert.
  • Everything is delicious but I highly recommend the Reese's Pieces deluxe sundae!
  • Burger was good
  • Strawberry Fruit Sensation is tasty and refreshing on a hot day!
  • Get a cheseburger and a small vanilla cone. De-lish!
  • Turkey or veggie Burger delicious grilled up with the works! Let, Tom, onion, pickle, ketchup & mustard!!!
  • Everything is delicious here! And don't forget about the half price cones when its snowing deal! :)
  • This is the place for custard in Buffalo. For all you fellow Canadians out there, this is NOT the same as, and much better than, "soft ice cream".
  • Great catering at a good price. I always get a few pounds of roast beef for Christmas Eve and goes over well.
  • Have loved this food since I was a kid
  • We had their orange sherbet today. Oh my was it delicious!! Creamy & rich wit not overpowering. Wish I could have some every day.
  • The beef on weck is good here.