St Peter's Catch

$ $ $
58 S Erie Ave (Lion's Field Park)
Montauk, NY 11954
(631) 668-7100
12:00pm - 8:00pm
12:00pm - 8:00pm
12:00pm - 8:00pm
12:00pm - 8:00pm
12:00pm - 9:00pm
12:00pm - 9:00pm
12:00pm - 8:00pm


  • The lobster roll isn't the biggest but it is filling and the tastiest! Only place that compares is a Boston lobster roll. Grab a growler from Montauk brewery and have yourself a wonderful day.
  • Excellent fish tacos. Their lobster special is spectacular. Enjoy with some fresh beer from the Montauk brewery next door.
  • Best shrimp n chips and fish tacos!! it's BYOB :)
  • The lobster Is amazing
  • fish dip - made w/smoked marlin - WOW
  • The king crab roll is killer!
  • Get the dip, you'll love it.
  • Lobster rolls are amazing!
  • The shrimp tacos are spicy and delicious!
  • Be prepared to wait in line, but it's worth it. BYOB so come with bevs ready or grab a growler at Montauk Brewing next door (MB closes around 6ish)
  • Hmmm. Fish n chips thumbs down too greasy. My friend had the lobster roll said it was delish. New England Clam yummo. I'll give it another shot.
  • Best fish and chips I've ever had. The fish is light and melts in your mouth! Plenty of outdoor seating, with a campfire and a hammock to boot!
  • Steamers were divine!!
  • the best fried fish tacos in montauk. the people who work there are great too!
  • More like a lobster slider, the lobster roll is embarrassingly small. Shame to because it was tasty.
  • Amazing food, the lobster roll was awesome and so was the chowder. The price for the amount of food you get for the lobster roll is not worth it at all. Go for the lobster meal or grabbin a $2 slice
  • Make sure you bring your own beer. Amazing food
  • Try their delicious fried shrimp - light and fluffy batter.
  • Sadly, it has closed.
  • The best fish tacos you'll ever have.

Nearby places

148 S Emerson Ave
161 Second House Rd