Pick A Bagel

Bagels, Breakfast
$ $
891 8th Ave (at W 53rd St.)
New York, NY 10019
(212) 582-8333
6:00am - 11:30pm
6:00am - 11:30pm
6:00am - 11:30pm
6:00am - 11:30pm
6:00am - 11:30pm
6:00am - 11:30pm
6:00am - 11:30pm



  • Nova Scotia Salmon on a Bagel with cream cheese. I die!
  • This place is the bomb. Bagels baked all day everyday. 20 types of spreads. Huge create your own salad bar. What's not to love.
  • Roll out bed, pick up bagel, roll back into bed
  • The flagels here are awesome, as are the wide variety of cream cheese options. A bit on the expensive end as far as bagels go, but they're still worth it here.
  • order "the @sarahmerion": sesame bagel scooped and toasted with lox cream cheese.
  • Best salad mix-ins ever! Fresh mozz balls with basil! If you are feeling naughty get the low-fat chicken salad on a scooped out bagel (creates a safe environment for your chicken salad)!
  • Don't be fooled by the cute bakery appearance and elaborate selection of fresh ingredients. Keep your order super simple, or be prepared to return to the counter a few times to fix it.
  • Ok. As a montrealer I'd always defend Montreal's bagels. But here I finally understood why NYC's Bagels can be delicious as well. Great choice of fresh bagels and combos. Perfect for breakfast.
  • They sell bagels here. Pick one, lol.
  • Amazing bagels and coffee
  • The pretax listed prices are slightly less than the pretax price on the receipt... shady.
  • Gets pretty crowded. Bagels are soft and chewy. Cream cheese is standard. Their lox is amazing but pricey as midtown goes. I'm still more partial to bklyn bagels.
  • Waited 35 minutes in line for a cold, sub par bagel. If there's a line I wouldnt recommend waiting.
  • Whole wheat everything w tofu scallion schmear... AMAZING!
  • Don't sit by the window around 10-11. The sun's gonna be hot!
  • whole wheat everything bagel is delish
  • Rip off 4$ for a bagel and cream cheese
  • Their everything bagels are amazing, even to this long island bagel snob!
  • Hooray for vegan options! Happy to find this place just around the corner of my hotel. Got a bagel with tofu cream cheese for breakfast every morning. Don't be worried about the line. It moves fast!
  • By far the best bagels in the area! A true new York bagel with loads of options!

Nearby places

59th St to 110th St (5th Ave to Central Park West)
11 W 53rd St (btwn 5th & 6th Ave)
4-6 Columbus Cir