Carmine's Pizzeria

Pizza, Italian
358 Graham Ave (btwn Conselyea St & Metropolitan Ave)
Brooklyn, NY 11211
(718) 782-9659
11:00am - 12:00am
11:00am - 12:00am
11:00am - 12:00am
11:00am - 12:00am
11:00am - 12:00am
11:00am - 12:00am
11:00am - 12:00am



  • Absolutely amazing pizza that has been around forever. Feels like family. Dozens of visits sometimes more than once a day- never tire of their food.
  • Very solid "local" pizza place. Nothing newfangled, just very good pizza, particularly IMO their white slice (try it with pepperoni) and their eggplant parm slice.
  • Pizza was late, sloppy and had metal in it. Talked to Carmine; he was rude and condescending. Been a customer 2 years. Brought my mom and baby there. Never felt so unvalued. Will never order again.
  • Arugula / grape tomato slice is out of control, but you gotta be there during lunch rush if you wanna catch one before they disappear.
  • Fantastic pizza, some of the best in the neighborhood. They also play every sports game you could want to watch.
  • Grandma pizza is great, they a great selection of different slices.
  • Full of Yankee theme stuff inside, this pizzeria is very well known for it's lasagna slice - highly recommend it.
  • Best pizza in the 'burg
  • Bruschetta was delicious along with the mozzarella sticks, the Philly cheese steak pizza was out of this world the pepperoni and sausage was ok..
  • Grandma slice forever
  • Try the Artichoke & Olive Sicilian Slice - #pizza #vegetarian
  • I second Mike Caprio. Go for the Philly Cheese Steak slice if it's available. UNREAL! One of the best slices I have ever consumed.
  • Now serving Brooklyn Lager on tap!
  • Yankees Fan Friendly This Is The Spot
  • Brooklyn Got The Best Pizza In The World
  • Eggplant parm is where it's at!
  • The Philly cheesesteak slice is pretty awesome... when they have it.
  • Good neighborhood slice, wouldnt go here if it was out of my way
  • Cant go wrong with the Tri-Color. Also the plain is solid. Best pizza in Williamsburg!
  • They seem to have an issue with people of color. On more then one occasion they have made many people I know feel like their business wasnt welcome. My daughter and her friends were ignored! Beware!

Nearby places

319 Frost St (at Debevoise St)
769 Metropolitan Ave (btwn Graham Ave & Humboldt St)
368 Graham Ave (btwn Skillman Ave & Conselyea St)