AJ's NY Pizzeria

301 Poyntz Ave (3rd Street)
Manhattan, KS 66502
(785) 587-0700
11:00am - 10:00pm
11:00am - 10:00pm
11:00am - 10:00pm
11:00am - 10:00pm
11:00am - 10:30pm
11:00am - 10:30pm
11:00am - 10:00pm



  • McSorleys black lager on tap...awesome!
  • Best pizza in town.
  • Fresh handmade dough (not the frozen crap that most restaurants use) cooked in their brick oven, great sauce, fresh veggies, and quality toppings make this the best pizza in town!
  • 50cent beer draws on Monday's that's super cheap beer.
  • Def not a NY style place. Tried it twice and tried various items each time. Certainly nothing to write home about. I'll go to old Chicago across the street.
  • Pizza is excellent....service is terrible especially if you have to deal with a worker named Josh...rude.
  • The 18th and 8th is probably the best pie on the menu.
  • Solid wings.
  • Salads are huge but delicious
  • My margarita pizza barely had any cheese
  • Pizza was good, but not good enough to make up for their lack of customer service skills.
  • The pastas are delicious
  • The Manhattan Margherita is my go-to here almost every time.
  • I love this place and come all the time. If you like good service this is not the place for you. They forget your order, bring you the wrong thing-if they bring anything at all. And they never listen
  • Biggest freshest garlic knots in human history.
  • When they ask if you want dipping sauce, get garlic butter, not ranch. Trust me.
  • Finally got the fifth avenue sign
  • Get the AJ's Grilled Cheese Pie
  • Great pizza, try the AJ's grilled cheese. Just stay out bathrooms...they stink
  • Try Monday's, they have 50 cent beers! U can't beat that!

Nearby places

100 Manhattan Town Ctr
317 Poyntz Ave (btwn N 3rd & 4th St)
601 North 3rd Place