Nick & Toni's

Italian, American
$ $ $ $
136 N Main St
East Hampton, NY 11937
(631) 324-3550
6:00pm - 10:00pm
6:00pm - 10:00pm
6:00pm - 10:00pm
6:00pm - 10:00pm
6:00pm - 10:00pm
11:30am - 2:30pm
6:00pm - 10:00pm



  • Can't get a rezzie? Eat at the bar!
  • Be sure to get olives for the table. Amazing!
  • The food is pretty good, but it's definitely worth it to listen to the obnoxious rich idiots sitting around you bragging about everything they can.
  • Sitting across from Nathan Lane on the patio is pretty cool! I'm actually star-struck! :)
  • ME: "Get the striped bass." YOU "But Sam! I don't li..." ME "shhhhh, get the striped bass."
  • Caesar salad and zucchini chips are incomparable. Service is always friendly and professional. It's not about the fancy hamptons celebrity scene, but the rooms have great energy, & the food is delish.
  • Try the Chocolate Honey Cake - Honey tuile, cocoa nib, local honey comb, whipped cream
  • Try the Penne - An incredibly consistent dish.
  • The patio makes an enjoyable location on a warm summer night the wait is worth it, we promise.
  • Go in off season when you can just walk in without a resi. Good beer selection. The crispy rabbit is a TON of food. Octopus salad doesn't skimp on octopus meat. And ricotta gnocchi is very good.
  • Not what I expected I thought it would be stuffy and serious in here. In true Hamptons style, local art lined the walls, fresh cut sunflowers filled vases and the dress code was relaxed.
  • Don't miss the zucchini chips!
  • I realize its the hot place to go in the summer, its better in the winter
  • penne pasta and shaved brussel sprouts are great dishes w. good size portions, but expensive for what they are. feel for the wait staff here as patrons are very demanding and at times, obnoxious.
  • Orechiette w sausage - good. Old fashioned was average.
  • excellent food and excellent service.
  • Great restaurant. So much fun great food and people watching Had razor clams and cheese platter for appetizers and rack of lamb entree. So good.
  • Whole roasted fish, drinks, pasta, desserts!
  • Solid cocktails with the right ice. Get there by 7:30 and you can grab seats at the bar.
  • I thought the zucchini chips weren't as crispy as they could have been, but the atmosphere was great, even in the winter!

Nearby places

99 Main St (at Cedar)
35 Newtown Ln (btw Main & Barns)
161 Main St (at Amagansett Square Dr)