May's Candy Shop
Map: Surroundings & Nearby
Best fudge on the island!
Buy 1 pound get a 1/2 pound free!
every place claims to be not only the best fudge, but also the original. these people had the most conviction. but I enjoyed the fudge elsewhere better. however, their other candy selection is great!
Best fudge ON the island! No doubt! :-D