Collegetown Bagels

Row 1

203 N Aurora St
Ithaca, NY 14850
(607) 273-2848
Bagels, Coffee Shop
Mon–Sun: 6:30 AM–8:00 PM

Foursquare Tips

  • I can't bring myself to call an everything bagel a "Long Island" bagel. They've been correcting me here for over 15 years ;)
  • Without any added hyperbole, the Bronx Bagel sandwich with Provolone on a Rosemary and Salt Bagel was the best breakfast sandwich I have ever had.
  • Friendly staff, great food.
  • Not only did it take them 15 mins to make my bagel, they gave me the wrong one. Labeled as mine, but inside wrong bagel. Don't do it
  • Best breakfast sandwiches in Ithaca. Avocado and a dash of hot sauce on mine please.
  • The country chicken soup tastes like it was made in the holy grail. So good!
  • All day Tuesday - sample our pesto,hummus and salsa. Discounts all day on dips,spreads and specialty cheeses.
  • The mullagatony (sp?) soup us great!
  • Breakfast here is great, fantastic food and better coffee
  • Soup and sandwich is always a good bet. Rosemary bagel pairs well with tuna or turkey.
  • Cannot go wrong with anything here... But shocked they RAN OUT OF BAGELS by noon!!!
  • Brooklyn on a Spicy!!!!!
  • Great vegetarian dishes! <3
  • Great way to start the day, I'm addicted to their bagels!
  • Salted Rosemary bagel is really good. Actually, I should probably just mention that these are good bagels.
  • Bagels with cream cheese. The eggs are just a cake of egg, though, don't bother.
  • Great bagels and coffee. And Ithaca institution
  • This is a bagel shop. The warm dirty water, may be the worst coffee I have ever had.
  • Compostable everything!
  • Tons of amazing sandwich combos. Live that they have gluten free options although the hand sliced pumpernickel is to die for.