Arcaro & Gennell's

Row 1

443 S Main St
Old Forge, PA 18518
(570) 457-4262
Italian, Pizza
$ $
Mon–Sat: 3:00 PM–11:00 PM

Foursquare Tips

  • My favorite Old Forge Pizza in the Pizza Capital of the World! Check out my full review of the OF Red and new bocce courts:
  • They Remodeled Looks great
  • Fine Italian food in the pizza capital of the world
  • Everything is great! A classic. The white pizza is amazing! Always great service.
  • Who knows they were closed! Guess they don't need the business!
  • Great pizza!!
  • The Tripe was the best I ever had!
  • Great food. Good service. The small antipasta is huge.
  • Delicious tonight. The white pizza with fresh tomato and basil on top--the best thing there, hands down.
  • Good pasta
  • Note: Pizza
  • One of the best I've had
  • Judy salad is the best kept secret in Old Forge.
  • Best Old Forge pizza.
  • get here at off-time to avoid crowd. slow service, nice staff. white pizza is da bomb (be sure to do extra shmmies in belly dance class to work it off)
  • The pizza is really good but the service is super Sloooooow . There is no free refills on ice tea or soda which sucks!!