The Seafood Shanty

Row 1

31 Dock St
Edgartown, MA 02539
(508) 627-8622
Seafood, American
$ $ $
Mon–Thu, Sun: 11:00 AM–9:00 PM Fri–Sat: 11:00 AM–10:00 PM

Around the Web

Foursquare Tips

  • The calamari at American Newes is better. Mussels had no flavor at all. Our server was rude. Not worth the $$$.
  • If you're looking to sip some dangerous sizzurp: Order up a Grapeful Dead - you will thank us the next morning - with well, whoever you "meet" ; ) - Zennan behind the bar is a god and patron saint
  • Go upstairs, grab a table on the deck, and enjoy fantastic views of Edgartown Harbor!
  • Sit at bar on deck. It's beautiful water view of Chappy! My see GaGa!
  • Stay away from the Captains Platter - tough whole belly clams, previously frozen shrimp, and flavorless haddock. The french fries were OK. Do yourself a favor and get it from Nancy's in Oak Bluffs.
  • The lobster quesadilla is a must-try!
  • This is a tourist trap to avoid unless you just like cocktails with a harbor view. The lobster rolls are pre made and not hot. Lobster quesadillas cold. Nothing fresh. Good French fries for kids
  • Be adventurous and try the local Katama oysters!
  • If in Edgartown this place is a must! Head up to the roof deck for amazing views
  • Best clams!!!
  • Order the best bloody mary with jumbo shrimp or the blueberry & acaia vodka with pink lemonade!! Portions are huge, sushi is good, you can't go wrong.
  • Shrimp and scallop scampi is mouth-watering. Buttery olive oily garlic-y goodness of pasta. Large portion so you won't leave hungry.
  • Ask for Justin or Damaris they really go above and beyond- made our experience great!
  • gt the shrimp cocktail. the fish 'n' chips. sit outside on the downstairs level. watch for the swan. it swims by, hoping for a snack.
  • Great spot for drinks on the water. And free popcorn! Get the local IPA, paired perfectly with said popcorn
  • Verify your order. Make sure you know what it comes with. My large to go order was not as expected based on how it was placed and I ended up having to spend more money to get what I actually ordered.
  • Fish sandwich, salmon roll, fries
  • Come for the view and to get a buzz on but not for the food or service
  • Food and views
  • Wonderful fish and chips!