Sammy's Fish Box Restaurant

Row 1

41 City Island Ave
Bronx, NY 10464
(718) 885-0920
Seafood, Steakhouse, Bar
$ $ $
Mon–Thu, Sun: 11:30 AM–2:00 AM Fri–Sat: 11:30 AM–3:00 AM

Foursquare Tips

  • Bread with cheese and warm cornbread before food? ! I'm in love already
  • Valet attendants work on tips!
  • Amazing food. Paella was delicious. It feeds an entire family. You've been warned. Huge meal.
  • Paella Valeciana is HUGE! It says it's for 2 people but at least 4 or 5 people can probably share
  • Portions are ginormous - split everything. Service is the worst, they are great at ignoring you. Look elsewhere...I'm sure you'll find a better seafood restaurant.
  • A little pricey, but delicious food and huge portions. You can't go wrong with any selection. I highly recommend Sammy's Fish Box!
  • Love this place! Been coming here since I was a kid...hands down best "Shrimp Scampi" I have ever had...good mixed drinks! Family place
  • I've been several times over several years & enjoy the atmosphere more than some of the other City Island restaurants. It can be pricey, but the mussels are great & the portions are extremely large.
  • Great food and service
  • Very delicious crabmeat salad!
  • Good food and large portions but they are not attentive to their customers. Won't be coming back.
  • That warm bread before the meal is so good. Shrimps are jumbo, no joke. .
  • The Paella is MASSIVE. Be Prepared!
  • Fried Jumbo Shrimp. Very good.
  • Order the shrimp scampi and definitly their apple martini!
  • I can't remember exactly what I ordered, but it was served in bowl. My companion and I ate maybe a quarter of it. It was delicious and we had no way to take the leftovers home.
  • Always come her when I want great fresh sea food. Never leave disappointed. Service is great.
  • The ambience is electric and the staff is so accommodating !
  • Portions are HUGE! Definitly more than one person can eat, especially with the bread you get and salad. Get an appetizer and share an entre if you're on a date. I'll definitely go back.
  • Crab legs and lobster were ok. The fish on the wood planks looks like what's up.