Vinny's of Carroll Gardens

$ $
295 Smith St (Btw. Union & Sacket)
Brooklyn, NY 11231
11:00am - 10:00pm
11:00am - 10:00pm
11:00am - 10:00pm
11:00am - 10:00pm
11:00am - 10:00pm
11:00am - 10:00pm
12:00pm - 9:00pm



  • awesome chicken soup if you have a cold. $6 with a loaf of italian bread.
  • get the ziti pomodoro. Best. Pomodoro. Ever.
  • Insanely large portions. Tastes like home. Frequented by NYPD AND FDNY, so you know it's the real deal.
  • Love the baked clams. Huge portions
  • Vinny is super friendly, been in the business 40 years! Food is great. No hipsters here, old school and neighborhoody.
  • Old school classic Brooklyn Italian food! The best of a dying breed. Total comfort food. Delicious dishes slathered in cheese and red sauce. Great service! Always packed!
  • Great Italian food & the staff is amaziiiing!!!
  • Eggplant Parm hero is like falling in love for the first time, every time.
  • The Chicken Parmigiana is great. You get enough to last you three meals.
  • like a cafeteria, most main dishes are not made to order but instead prepared earlier in the day, then re-heated for serving. as such, go with oven-baked items such as the tasty eggplant parmigiana.
  • the fra diavolo is fra delicious
  • Everything!! Serving size is great!! Will definitely have some to take home..
  • Best Family Style Italian
  • Baked ziti baked in the microwave??? Yup saw them do it!
  • Your classic Italian American restaurant. Hearty sizes with home cooked Italian food. My go to? Bolognese.
  • Really good traditional Italian food. Big portions
  • So disappointed. Lasagna tasted like canned ravioli. Carbonara not good. Green beans were from a can. Won't be coming back, much better Italian in the area.
  • Meat lasagna the size of your head. Absolutely delicious, too.
  • Great for lunch. And dinner. And breakfast the next day. Huge portions of Classic New York Italian cuisine.
  • Eat. Share. Repeat.

Nearby places

280 Smith St (at Sackett St)
269 Court St (at Butler St.)
268 Smith St