Atlantic Fish And Chop House

Row 1

2 Main St
Edgartown, MA 02539
(508) 627-7001
American, Steakhouse
$ $ $
Mon–Sun: Noon–11:00 PM

Foursquare Tips

  • Ask for Ben or Cordelia! Reall
  • The Lobster Arugula salad is definitely worth having! A generous amount of lobster and delicious strawberry vinaigrette, what more could you ask for? A perfect lunch! And great views from the deck.
  • Jamie at the front is a tool.
  • The Dom Perignon and Truffle Fries Deal is Awesome.
  • Free Bacon at the bar
  • The live music starts in May. Don't miss it!!!
  • Best late night scene in Edgartown when we visited in late May. Drinks and food were both excellent. Their lobster dishes are amazing!
  • Good lobster and beers
  • Management is pompous, self-involved and clearly unhelpful to their undertrained service staff. Decent place for cocktails and apps. Don't waste your money for dinner!
  • Maitre d is a douche...go to the shanty
  • Stay away. Worst service on the NE.
  • Live music and some of the best people watching on the island - love it!
  • Bryant and Cordelia are great! Food is excellent. Truffle fries a must.
  • Pretty mean Martinis coming out of this joint and enough good looking people to get the scene poppin - great food, but we prefer to hit the drink scene and the occasional Dance Party with Band or DJ!
  • go late. go when they have live music. sit at the bar. drink the strong drinks. have fun.
  • Great place to eat and enjoy good company. Excellent friendly service. Deserves 9/10
  • Stay away! This is a pure tourist trap...the food is not fresh, the wait staff is horrible and the noise level prohibits a table conversation. It is highly overpriced!!
  • You can't go wrong with the bone-in ribeye.
  • The sea bass is awesome, order the brussels sprouts and asparagus to top off the meal. Potatoes augrautin won't disappoint either.
  • The beet salad is delicious!