Anthony's Pizza

$ $
3385 S US Highway 17/92 (at Button Rd.)
Casselberry, FL 32707
(407) 782-9501
11:00am - 10:00pm
11:00am - 10:00pm
11:00am - 10:00pm
11:00am - 10:00pm
11:00am - 11:00pm
11:00am - 11:00pm
12:00pm - 10:00pm


  • Amazing white pizza and calzone. Yummmm
  • I was very disappointed. The servers weren't very friendly and ordered a medium size pizza and they have it to be almost on the burnt side. I will probably not come back again.
  • Best NY style pizza in Orlando. Garlic knots are excellent, they use real chopped garlic. Veggie Supreme is fantastic and I never order veggie anywhere else!
  • The best pizza in town we order lunch from them all the time.
  • Chicken Parm is excellent. My favorite in town and enough for two meals all for only ten bucks
  • Stuffed veggie pizza is amazing!!
  • Awesome pies! Authentic NY style pizza, blessed to be so close.
  • Just a small pizza place that makes delicious food!
  • Extra cheese pizza & their garlic knots....
  • We don't get out much, but when we do with Pizza in mind, it's straight to Anthony's. Once you've had it, NOTHING else will suffice! AWESOME GUYS!!
  • Great cannolis (sp?) XD
  • Best pizza in town- Order the spinach and crush tomatoes pizza with garlic and thank me later.
  • The cook at this place with the weird eye is some kinda freak. No way im going to this place again
  • Best pizza ever!!
  • This is one of THE BEST pizza joints around!
  • Best meatballs!
  • Great calamari. Anthony's Special Pizza is AMAZING! If you order the spinach and tomato, ask them to drain the spinach first.
  • The best pizza since you left New York. Say hi to Chucky makin the pies.
  • Hands down the best pie in town!
  • The pizza looks better than it taste!!

Nearby places

3385 S US Highway 17/92 Ste 181 (at Button Rd)