Peter Pan Diner

Row 1

854 Sunrise Hwy
Bay Shore, NY 11706
(631) 665-1788

Foursquare Tips

  • Ask for Marsha....
  • The greek salad and wrap are the best! Love the jumbo burgers. Curly fries are awesome. Cole slaw is yummy. Love the gyros. They give you plenty of food. Ugh food is just so tasty!
  • Looking for good food in Bat Shore then don't pass up the "Peter Pan Diner". Great food and awesome people!
  • Tim is still the best and the food is great!!
  • Great food, quick service and courteous and energetic employees.
  • Burgers are delicious, get the deluxe because the cole slaw is the best!
  • Try the Mango Tango Wrap it has no mango at all on it but its delicious! Laura is a great waitress, funny and personable...puts you in a good mood!
  • Donna is great... French onion soup and blt is the way to go..
  • There waitress staff is very rude!!!
  • Check out the grilled cheese menu
  • There's always great service, even during their dinner rush. The food isn't particularly expensive for a diner. I recommend the chicken caesar salad wrap with french fries and a chocolate shake.
  • Feta cheese & tomato omelette is so good!
  • The gyro is good.
  • Best Diner in the neighborhood by far
  • The steak quesdilla is a must try... Love the food!
  • He blueberry almond pancakes was fantastic
  • My Gyros was yummy.
  • This place is usually crowded.
  • BEST French onion soup
  • You must try the New Champ its to die for!

Around the Web