The Milk Pail

Farmer's Market, Donuts
1346 Montauk Hwy
Watermill, NY 11976
(631) 537-2565


  • Open All Winter!
  • This location is back to being open year-round. The apple cider donuts are amazing - try to get them right out of the fryer. Excellent cider, pies and applesauce that they make themselves.
  • As much as you can fill in their bags!
  • Warm cinnamon sugar cider donut!

Nearby places

Horseblock Lane (off Mecox Road)
139 Sagg Rd (at Montauk Hwy)
829 Montauk Highway