Make My Cake

Row 1

121 Saint Nicholas Ave (at 116th St.)
New York, NY 10026
(212) 932-0822
$ $
Mon–Thu: 8:00 AM–8:00 PM Fri: 8:00 AM–9:00 PM Sat: 9:00 AM–9:00 PM Sun: 9:00 AM–7:00 PM

Foursquare Tips

  • Think Soup Nazi like on Seinfeld but with cupcakes. Delish though for us sugar addicts. Unkind on the waistline... But we've gotta live, right? :-)
  • One of the places Tina Fey mentions as her favorite cupcake places in NYC on 30 rock. Go with the red velvet
  • The cakes and pies here will put your grandparents and great aunts out of business. The cafe is large and roomy, which allows the traffic to flow. Ask for pumpkin cheesecake and you'll be hooked.
  • Fresh pastries and deep dish cakes made to order! Worth every penny!
  • Carrot cake was disgusting!! Customer service was really lacking too. I will never waste another $5 there ever again!! Save your money! Or be disappointed.
  • Must order Red Velvet! Slice, not cupcake.
  • This is the one and only place you should purchase buttercream frosting cake in Harlem. Only here. Get it by the slice and thank me later. Sorry but the cupcakes don't have enough frosting for me.
  • Yummy! The red velvet is so moist and I also love the lemon frosted. Each cupcake is huge- good for sharing!
  • The blueberry cobbler is fantastic!
  • The coconut pecan cookie = LOVE
  • FAB red velvet cake!
  • Mmmmm. . . Red Velvet cake and Sweet Potato Pie!!
  • Super slow. Order was supposed to be ready by 6PM. Got here @ 7:15 & they still weren't done.
  • Family-run bakery known for colorful, customized birthday & wedding cakes. The layer cake will make you call when birthday time comes around - half a slice just might be enough.
  • Although cakes are the focal point Cookies very inexpensive and soooo yummy.
  • Yummy butter cream frosting!
  • Incredible!!
  • Incredible!!
  • Get the Red Velvet cake.

Around the Web