Luke's Lobster

$ $
426 Amsterdam Ave (btw W 80th & 81st St)
New York, NY 10024
(212) 877-8800
11:00am - 10:00pm
11:00am - 10:00pm
11:00am - 10:00pm
11:00am - 10:00pm
11:00am - 11:00pm
11:00am - 11:00pm
11:00am - 10:00pm



  • Village Voice is excited to have Luke's Lobster at the 2012 ChoiceEats food fest! Full list of restaurants here:
  • If you're getting a lobster roll anywhere besides Luke's, you're getting a second rate lobster roll.
  • Totally bland. The pickle was the best part. Either BYOOB (bring your own old bay) or go to Oaxaca Taco next door. Supes cheaper and totes DELISH!
  • Beer isn't kept cold enough. Solid lobster roll. Order it CT-style (sans mayo).
  • Tried Noah's Ark~ Love all three rolls!
  • Try the A Taste Of Maine Combo - Half lobster roll, half crab roll, half shrimp roll, full gloriousness
  • Same great lobster rolls as the East Village spot but we still recommend the Taste of Maine as the best bang for your buck. Best part of this location? You can now have it delivered!
  • Sign up for LocalBonus to automatically earn points towards a free Schooner Combo or Noah's Ark! (You can even double dip by also using your Lobsta Mobsta card!)
  • Lobster so good it must be breaking a claw.
  • Splurge on the taste of Maine , I liked all three.
  • New York Citys freshest, most affordable lobster roll in now available on the Upper West Side! Our favorite remains the Noahs Ark.
  • Great location, has indoor and outdoor seating. One of the best, affordable Lobster Rolls in the city. Served cold, healthy portion of large chunks of sweet meat. Bread doesn't overpower the lobster.
  • Everything here is great......
  • Need 2 rolls for a legit meal
  • The cold Maine-style and hot Connecticut-style lobster rolls are some of the best in the city.
  • Taste of Maine! Always get the Taste of Maine!
  • The shrimp roll is actually the best one
  • #fabuLIST lobster roll combo
  • Costs a little more but worth every penny.
  • Excellent food but expensive for how small the rolls are. Lobster > crab > shrimp IMO

Nearby places

200 Central Park W (btwn W 77th & W 81st St)
167 W 74th St (at Amsterdam Ave)
2310 Broadway (btwn W 83rd & W 84th St)