Citarella Gourmet Market - Upper West Side

Row 1

2135 Broadway (at 75th St)
New York, NY 10023
(212) 874-0383
Grocery Store, Seafood, Sushi
Mon–Sat: 7:00 AM–10:00 PM Sun: 9:00 AM–9:00 PM

Foursquare Tips

  • House blend coffee is good and cheap!!
  • Believe it or not, upstairs at Citarella is great for rich chocolate and mocha-flavored cakes and fine cupcakes. It also has very good meat, and produce that is consistently better than Fairway's.
  • Great seafood. -Carmen Gonzalez, Top Chef
  • They have some of the best prepared food in the city.
  • Best bread in nyc!
  • Great "picerie fine" especially good for fish, bread, charcuterie and cheese.
  • Fresh bread or rolls are the bomb, but go quickly!!
  • Citarella is the place youre guaranteed to find whatever high-end item you randomly find yourself needing, be it fresh truffles or a whole rabbit.
  • One of the best seafood markets in NYC.
  • Mini gourmet market!!
  • Fresh fish is incredible. Ask for Steve at the counter, he's the best!
  • Amazing fish selection and always fresh. Staff will always help you with cleaning or cutting if you don't feel like doing it at home.
  • Great upscale grocery store, good for prepared foods and salads
  • Great selection of prepared foods for any occasion.
  • Good place to get quality meat and bread
  • Fresh warm baguettes
  • Great gourmet shop! Has high quality steaks and big lobsters!
  • Generally the best fish in NYC. But I'm not impressed with their $14 a pound tuna salad. It's way too salty, too dry and doesn't have enough celery bits. Glad I only got 1/4 pound!
  • Bellini in a can?
  • Don't forget about upstairs! Seems much quieter up here