Calderone Club

$ $
842 N Old World 3rd St (Kilbourne Ave)
Milwaukee, WI 53203
(414) 273-3236



  • Rectangular pizzas & great pasta. What's not to love?
  • The Chicken Marsala is sensational, not unlike the staff.
  • Penne con Salsiccia Piccante is one in a million.
  • Everything here is fantastic!
  • If your not hungry at least sit at the bar and have a chat with Larry the bartender and the locals....great time!!!!
  • Nice place across the street from the Hyatt but VERY noisy. They need to add some carpet, drapes or something to cancel some noise.
  • They don't charge for refills on soft drinks anymore.
  • BIG pizza and the BEST Chicken Marsala around. You can even build your own pasta!
  • Busy and loud -- and for good reason. The food is excellent and the service is first rate b
  • If you order a soft drink, you have to pay for a refill. Plus the glass is full of ice. No thanks!
  • Best bartender ever!!!!!! Ilario!!! Adore him!
  • If the waitress tells you the large pizzas are 10x12, she's lying. They're at LEAST 12x14.
  • Many great choices, a welcoming and helpful staff, amazing food, and a fun atmosphere.
  • Food was incredible and the Service was even better. Meatballs are a must.
  • I have walked by here several times and someone recommended eating here. Really good! Try the spice penne with sausage. Wait staff is awesome!
  • This is one of the best Italian restaurants I have ever been to. The house salad with homemade Italian dressing was fabulous. I also had the cannelloni, which had a perfect blend of 4 cheeses.
  • Meatballs! Meatballs! Meatballs!
  • Of course the pizza, but the pasta dishes are great too. Can be loud when busy, but great service and food.
  • Fresh made Pasta to die for.
  • Great food, great service. Nothing to complain, a lot to point out.

Nearby places

500 W Kilbourn Ave
929 N Water St (State St)
779 N Front St (at W Wells St)