Cafe Formaggio

Italian, Wine Bar
$ $
307 Old Country Rd
Carle Place, NY 11514
(516) 333-1718



  • The gluten free menu is enormous! Its a must visit for people with Celiac.
  • You have got to get the cappalini balls. Best thing I ever ate in my life!
  • Pizza pies for only $8.99! and the taste good too.
  • Phenomenal food and service! Must order salmon...just MELTS in mouth!
  • Salmon Dijon aka Salmon Trapani is worth it
  • Fantastic gluten free menu. A must have for celiacs!
  • Yummy food, but portions r pretty big, so share appetizers
  • We are in town from Philadelphia Pa and I can happily say the food was amazing! The ambiance was very cozy and cute and our waiter was awesome. Next time we are in town for business we will surel...
  • As alway the food and service was spectacular. The waiter saw me reading the GF menu and right away brought me GF bread. This is the best place for safe GF dining and I recommend it to all my GF ...
  • All the food options were good and each gluten free option was great as well. We came for graduation lunch and we come here often for the gluten free food since I have to eat it for dietary reaso...
  • Fabulous! We traveled from Connecticut because we heard such great things! The food was amazing from start to finish. And Frank was a dream! Thank you for a marvelous experience!
  • We had a great experience from the minute we walked In until we finished our delicious meal! We were seated promptly, food was served in a timely manor and it was super! Our waiter is one of o...
  • The best restaurant in Long Island! The waiter is outstanding, very friendly and welcoming. Will definitely be back. The cheesecake and cappuccino is excellent!
  • My wife has celiac and we travel all the way from Brooklyn for your wonderful gluten free menu such a great selection and the standard Italian diner is always supreme. The best !! And Lenny is as...
  • AMAZING!!! The food and staff were fantastic! The next time we are back in LI we will def make a trip back! Everything on the menu was delicious and there wasn't a single complaint in our group o...
  • I was amazed by the extensive gluten free menu and all the options that was offered. As well as the many options of gluten free desserts and personal bread as well. The waiter was amazing, attent...
  • Great food for someone who is gluten free I never have to worry. Lenny is the best waiter he knows exactly what we order and makes us feel at home. We love the food but we love Lenny's service an...
  • Beyond expectation service. Waiters are amazingly friendly. Delicious food baked clams are the bomb!
  • Fantastic massage after my sexy sangria!!!
  • All the food was excellent, including the breads. One of our guests wanted butter for the bread, but we didn't ask.

Nearby places

630 Old Country Rd (btwn Clinton Rd & Meadowbrook State Pkwy)
910 Old Country Rd (at The Gallery At Westbury Plaza)