It’s fall, so that means pumpkin spice is everywhere. The autumnal flavor previously only for young women wearing Uggs and yoga pants has become so widespread that it’s hardly considered “basic” anymore. Not only can you can buy pumpkin spice bagels, hummus, cereal, candy, body wash, lotion and candles in stores, but you can purchase a pumpkin spice latte at pretty much any café you wander in to — even the swanky ones not named Starbucks. However, not all PSLs are made the same. If you’re looking to escape the cloying sweetness of a Starbucks PSL and enjoy a real tasty pumpkin drink, you need to know where to go.
The Daily Meal has worked with review-based website Yelp to find the best pumpkin spice latte in every state that’s not from Starbucks. Yelp identified businesses in the restaurant and food categories with a large concentration of reviews mentioning "pumpkin spice latte" or "PSL," then ranked those spots using a number of factors including the total volume and ratings of reviews mentioning "pumpkin spice latte" and "PSL."
While some of these cafés offer the drink seasonally, many offer the cinnamon-y pumpkin beverage all year round. The best of the best flavor their beverages with pumpkin puree rather than too-sweet syrup, but some people in some states like their PSLs to taste more like candy (we’re looking at you Wisconsin) than spice. So before you kick off fall with your first pumpkin spice latte of the season, know where to go. These are the best pumpkin spice lattes in every state that aren’t from Starbucks.
Aside from having a cheerful name, the customers at Cherry Bean in Denver are smiling because they find this café's PSL extra tasty. “I wouldn't have opted for the pumpkin spice but they make the syrup in house and it was fantastic!” wrote one enthusiastic reviewer.
The PSL at The Point Coffee House and Bake Shoppe pairs excellently with the café’s sticky buns, egg and cheddar croissant and even their Waldorf chicken salad sandwich, according to one Yelper.
Not only does Revolution Doughnuts sell pumpkin spice doughnuts, they have a pretty delicious pumpkin spice latte on their menu. “By itself, the latte is not sweet at all (which tells me they don't use artificial, low quality syrups. Love that!) if that's what you'd prefer. However they have sugar and agave that you can add to suit your taste,” one Yelper advised.
Many of Cedar Grove Coffee House’s reviews talk about their excellent pumpkin spice latte. The little shop even has a selection of paninis and will offer your dog (if you bring one) a dish of whipped cream.
Customers flock to this New Orleans café for its pumpkin spiced lattes and local favorites like Café Envie’s “breakfast in a cup”. The order is a disposable cup filled with grits, hash browns, sausage, gravy, eggs, and bacon. Yum!
Not only does The Songbird Café serve a pumpkin spice latte that Yelpers call “delicious” and “amazing,” they serve a cardamom rose latte that’s supposed to also be excellent.
This doughnut shop has pumpkin spice everything! They offer pumpkin spice lattes, coffees, doughnuts, and more. It’s called “The Tatonut” because the shop uses potatoes instead of flour in their recipe.
There are a few different kinds of pumpkin spice lattes at Fox Hollow Coffee in Omaha. There’s the “Great White” Pumpkin latte, dark pumpkin latte, and a pumpkin pie latte, all of which their customers say are delicious.
Tucker’s in New Hampshire has all the pumpkin breakfast goodies you could ever want. They serve excellent PSLs, pumpkin pancakes, pumpkin coffee, and more. But, it does get crowded. “There's always a wait, but you can help yourself to a mug of coffee while you wait and they keep things moving. Just budget 30 mins of wait time in,” wrote a Yelper.
This seasonal item is a favorite of customers to Bwè Kafe.” I absolutely love their Spice latte it is one of a kind! Amazing you must try — beats out the Starbucks Pumpkin Spice latte 1000 times over,” wrote a Yelper.
The Brew has tons of tasty drinks like their Jack Skellington, aka their pumpkin pie latte. Many reviews say that it is the “perfect level of sweetness.” Also, the actors from the popular TV show “Better Call Saul” have been known to frequent this place.
It’s nice to know that even trendy New Yorkers are not immune to the allure of pumpkin spice lattes. When they crave the sweet orange drink, they head to 12 Corners Coffee. Not only does the drink look amazing — their Instagram has tons of tasty looking photos with PSLs decorated in latte art — according to reviews it also tastes divine.
“Greatest pumpkin spice latte ever. Can definitely taste the nutmeg and cinnamon. If you love spiced drinks definitely get this,” wrote a Yelper of Sola Coffee Café’s PSL.
“Today the pumpkin spice latte blows the Starbucks version outta the park, but in past visits I've swooned over maple rosemary, rose, oatmeal, and lavender lattes,” wrote a reviewer of Clarity Coffee’s drink menu.
If you’re visiting Portland and craving a spicy pumpkin drink, stop by Flying Cat Coffee. They’re known for having the best pumpkin spice latte in Oregon. “Five stars for the pumpkin spice latte. The sign outside claiming real pumpkin caught my attention. They weren't kidding — so delicious, decadent without being sickly sweet. I will never have a Starbucks PSL again, for I have seen the light,” someone commented on Yelp.
For at least one Yelper, the experience of trying Orange Spot Coffee’s PSL was a genuine epiphany. “I wasn't sure if I wanted the pumpkin spice latte or not (so sue me for feeling conformist; I was wearing yoga pants and flannel, after all!) and she said that it was actually made from real pumpkin! I had to try it. At first, I wasn't sure if I liked it, but then I realized it was because the latte wasn't like other pumpkin lattes — it wasn't sickeningly sweet, but rich and complex. No Starbucks-y syrup-y grossness for me anymore. That latte was great.”
Everybody loves Coffea Roasterie’s wide selection of teas and lattes. This local café uses high quality ingredients to make all their baked goods and sweet drinks such as their pumpkin spice latte, which they call their “Charlie Brown latte.”
Crema knows what they’re doing making their pumpkin spice latte. Many reviews have celebrated that it’s nothing like Starbucks, saying it isn’t “sickly sweet” like those from the chain. “It’s comforting and it is definitely my go-to now,” wrote a reviewer.
Fourteen Eighteen Coffeehouse serves pumpkin spice lattes all year round. They’re topped with cinnamon! Mmm.
“Excellent pumpkin spice lattes... great ambiance and location right on Main St. Will be back the next time we're in Park City!” commented a Yelper of Atticus Coffee.
This Earth-conscious café is a local favorite for its reasonable prices, great food, and fantastic pumpkin spice lattes! The Brown Cow Café also has a ton of vegetarian and vegan options.
Be sure to check out De Clieu Coffee’s pumpkin pie latte which one Yelper says is, “a great balance of flavors and not overly sweet.” They also sell pumpkin muffins!
“This place does not use some random factory made syrup for their Pumpkin Spice lattes. They make a homemade Pumpkin puree and dissolve it into your drink. You can't find this kind of flavor and originality just anywhere,” wrote a Yelper of Wheeling Coffee Shoppe.
This Cody coffee shop is frequently described as “warm and inviting” which is exactly how you want the place you pick up your PSL from to be. Rawhide Coffee has tons of coffee and latte flavors, but the fan favorite is pumpkin spice. It’s the best pumpkin spice latte in Wyoming, For those who can’t make the drive to Cody, these are the best and worst store-bought PSLs.
More From The Daily Meal: