America's 25 Favorite Home-Cooked Dishes

Slide Image
25. Food.com's Ice Cubes
Headline
25. Food.com's Ice Cubes
Description

We’re not going to lie, we were hoping this recipe was going to make the list considering how ridiculous it is. Based on the same metrics for all of the other recipes, this recipe, with all of its sarcasm and simplicity aside, is one of the top 25 recipes that America loves to make. Why? Who knows, but we can tell you that it had 64,000 Facebook likes and a large quantity of user ratings compared to its fellow recipes found on the same site. It’s pretty clever, and we hate when the ice tray is left empty, too. But if you’re going to write an ice cube recipe, at least do it right. 

Click here to see our Ice Cubes Recipe

Credit

Jupiterimages

Slide Image
24. Paula Deen's Pumpkin
Headline
24. Paula Deen's Pumpkin
Description

With another pumpkin recipe just making this list, we’re pretty sure America is a fan of pumpkin, and of Paula Deen. We’d prefer to skip the cream cheese icing, though, and enjoy our pumpkin bars sprinkled with some chocolate chips.

Credit

Thinkstock/iStockphoto

Slide Image
23. Taste of Home's Mozzarella Sticks
Headline
23. Taste of Home's Mozzarella Sticks
Description

Who doesn’t love a good fried mozzarella stick? Taste of Home’s version makes it easy to create that crunchy outside and cheesy, gooey inside with store-bought egg roll wrappers.

We’re all about ease, too, which is why we like this fried mozzarella recipe by Mario Batali. We think it creates that mozzarella stick-appeal and is just as easy, and maybe more natural, than Taste of Home’s.

Credit

Shutterstock.com

Slide Image
22. Betty Crocker's Ranch Chicken
Headline
22. Betty Crocker's Ranch Chicken
Description

This four-ingredient recipe packs a lot of flavor considering how little effort and time it takes, which is probably why it’s one of America’s favorites. Any chicken dish can easily be updated with just one or two additions to its flavor, like with our Parmesan Chicken Fries recipe. This recipe not only serves up delicious chicken, but it sneaks in a few good ingredients to make it healthy for you, too.

Credit

Thinkstock/iStockphoto

Slide Image
21. Betty Crocker's Impossibly Easy Mini Chicken Pot Pies
Headline
21. Betty Crocker's Impossibly Easy Mini Chicken Pot Pies
Description

Chicken pot pie is another popular recipe on this list, and while this one is much lower in the ranks, we think it earned its place because of its ability to serve a crowd easily. You can certainly go ahead and make our Pillsbury chicken pot pie version in a muffin tin as well, or you can try a different handheld treat like our mini cheeseburger pies. 

Credit

Thinkstock/iStockphoto

Slide Image
20. Food.com's Fannie Farmer's Classic Baked Macaroni and Cheese
Headline
20. Food.com's Fannie Farmer's Classic Baked Macaroni and Cheese
Description

Food.com' macaroni and cheese recipe is a vintage piece from the 1946 edition of Fannie Farmer’s Boston Cooking-School Cookbook. We can’t compete with Fannie Farmer, unless you were looking for a healthier version, in which case we’d suggest you try our PointsPlus recipe for the same results.

 

Credit

Alexandra Rowley

Slide Image
19. Paul Deen's Southern Fried Chicken
Headline
19. Paul Deen's Southern Fried Chicken
Description

You can’t argue with Paula’s skills with anything Southern or fried, which is probably why this recipe declares its place on America’s top 25 favorite recipes list. If you love fried chicken just as much as the rest of the country does, then why not try our slightly different (and we think better) version? Infused with saffron, our buttermilk marinade does a number on the pre-fried chicken, and our frying technique is pretty spot-on. 

Credit

Multi-bits

Slide Image
18. Tyler Florence's Chicken Enchiladas
Headline
18. Tyler Florence's Chicken Enchiladas
Description

This Food Network recipe is one that users can’t get enough of, and we can’t blame them. Loaded with hot chiles, onions, garlic, and Cheddar and Jack cheeses, it’s the classic enchilada recipe made in traditional Tyler Florence style. That being said, we think Recipe editor Will Budiaman’s version, with a homemade pico de gallo and green sauce, merits a look, too. 

Credit

Shutterstock.com

Slide Image
17. Betty Crocker's Banana Bread
Headline
17. Betty Crocker's Banana Bread
Description

Betty Crocker is a baking icon, which is why it makes sense that this banana bread recipe would earn enough attention to be placed on this list. We don’t want to hurt Betty’s feelings or anything, but Blackbird Bakery’s gluten-free version is just as satisfying and a little better for you, too. While it’s optional, we urge you to not skip out on the cream cheese frosting.

 

Credit

Shutterstock.com

Slide Image
16. Food.com's Pulled Pork
Headline
16. Food.com's Pulled Pork
Description

This Food.com recipe for pulled pork spends a lot of time in the slow cooker. We know, it has to, which is why we love Ray Lampe’s (the Dr. BBQ) version, which uses fresh apple juice in the recipe instead of the soda in Food.com’s.  

Credit

Shutterstock.com

Slide Image
15. Allrecipe's Too Much Chocolate Cake
Headline
15. Allrecipe's Too Much Chocolate Cake
Description

A chocolaty devil’s food cake and creamy icing made from chocolate pudding earn this popular recipe the title of "too much" chocolate. It’s also pretty easy to put together. But if you like the stress-free route, then there’s nothing easier than the microwave.

Credit

PX Photography

Slide Image
14. Alton Brown's The Chewy
Headline
14. Alton Brown's The Chewy
Description

Alton Brown is one of Food Network’s most popular personalities, and so we’re not surprised to see his recipe for chewy chocolate chip cookies show up on this list. His are pretty good, but sometimes we like a little crunch in our cookie, so we throw in a handful of walnuts when we make ours.

Credit

Shutterstock.com

Slide Image
13. Food.com's To Die for Crock Pot Roast
Headline
13. Food.com's To Die for Crock Pot Roast
Description

This recipe is e-a-s-y. That's why we think it’s one of America’s favorites to use from Food.com. For a different (read: better) dish, try our version with about the same amount of all-natural ingredients. But in ours, we skip the dried package of gravy and use some Guinness instead. 

Credit

Shutterstock.com

Slide Image
12. Food.com's Easy Garlic Chicken
Headline
12. Food.com's Easy Garlic Chicken
Description

With only two ingredients, this recipe for chicken creates a ton of flavor with minimal effort, and America can’t get enough of it. While we like the use of brown sugar in Food.com’s version, we prefer a little crunch to our garlic chicken.

Credit

Shutterstock.com

Slide Image
11. Ina Garten's Mac and Cheese
Headline
11. Ina Garten's Mac and Cheese
Description

We were happy to see this macaroni and cheese recipe by Food Network’s Ina Garten make the list. It’s one of our favorites, too. Because we’re in the competitive spirit, though, why don’t you try fellow TV star Bobby Flay’s macaroni and cheese carbonara, made with not two, but five different cheeses. Come on, even the name sounds better. 

Credit

Shutterstock.com

Slide Image
10. Allrecipe's Mom's Zucchini Bread
Headline
10. Allrecipe's Mom's Zucchini Bread
Description

Some of us think that just having the word "mom" in this recipe’s title probably earned it some street cred, but once we tried it out, we realized that it’s nice and moist, too. While we can’t credit mom for our version, this zucchini bread recipe is made into easy-to-serve squares, is gluten-free, and has chocolate chips in it. What would your mom think about that?

Credit

C-Squared Studios

Slide Image
9. Taste of Home's Peanut Butter Chocolate Dessert
Headline
9. Taste of Home's Peanut Butter Chocolate Dessert
Description

While not a huge hit with users ratings on Taste of Home’s website, this peanut butter and chocolate treat garnered enough attention to be number two on their list, and it also saw a lot of love from Facebook. No surprise there, seeing as there are very few people in America who can resist the combination of these two rich ingredients. Taste of Home wasn’t the only one to think this one up, though, and our Magnolia Bakery version might just be even tastier.

Credit

Shutterstock.com

Slide Image
8. Allrecipe's Fluffy Pancakes
Headline
8. Allrecipe's Fluffy Pancakes
Description

This popular recipe makes pancakes extra fluffy by combining white vinegar with the milk for the batter. They’re "just right," says an Allrecipes.com user.  But for an ultra-healthy take on the breakfast staple, try these banana-pecan pancakes, which are  made with unprocessed, all-natural ingredients and are topped with a chocolate-coconut drizzle, which the Kicking Cancer in the Kitchen authors say improves metabolism, boosts energy, and promotes weight loss. 

Slide Image
7. Allrecipe's Apple Pie by Grandma Ople
Headline
7. Allrecipe's Apple Pie by Grandma Ople
Description

There’s no beating grandma’s apple pie, which is probably why this contest-winning recipe is one of America’s favorites. Because there’s no topping it, we went the outrageous route with our McDonald’s Apple Pie and Taco Bell Cinnamon Crisp Crumble recipe. You just might win some local competitions with it, too. 

Credit

Shutterstock.com

Slide Image
6. Allrecipe's Downeast Maine Pumpkin Bread
Headline
6. Allrecipe's Downeast Maine Pumpkin Bread
Description

This New England classic is moist and spicy, and is great to have lying around, considering AllRecipes.com user Laurie Bennett’s opinion that it only gets better with age. Our pumpkin bread recipe isn’t from Maine, but it is good for anyone looking to follow a paleo or gluten-free diet. 

Credit

Shutterstock.com

Slide Image
5. Allrecipe's Delicious Ham and Potato Soup
Headline
5. Allrecipe's Delicious Ham and Potato Soup
Description

We think this hearty potato soup, loaded with salty bites of ham, earns its popular reputation from its ease and versatility. For a unique twist on potato soup that cuts out the meat, try our version that takes advantage of an immersion blender. 

Credit

Thinkstock/iStockphoto

Slide Image
4. Allrecipe's Clone of a Cinnabon
Headline
4. Allrecipe's Clone of a Cinnabon
Description

We like this clone of a Cinnabon recipe found on Allrecipes.com, and America did, too, giving it a lot of love on both the website and on Facebook. If you’re looking for the real deal, though (and half the calories), make our version by The New York Times best-selling author Devin Alexander. 

Credit

Shutterstock.com

Slide Image
3. Allrecipe's Banana Crumb Muffins
Headline
3. Allrecipe's Banana Crumb Muffins
Description

While this recipe garnered a bit of support from Facebook, it received its real love from the users of Allrecipes.com. We think the craze is all about the "crumble" that it’s topped with, made with brown sugar and cinnamon. OK, that’s pretty hard to beat, but what if our recipe was gluten-free and had chocolate in it? 

Credit

Shutterstock.com

Slide Image
2. Allrecipe's Chicken Pot Pie IX
Headline
2. Allrecipe's Chicken Pot Pie IX
Description

This chicken pot pie recipe created by Allrecipes.com user Robbie Rice makes a quick and easy meal with a handful of vegetables and pre-made pie crusts. Want to know what’s easier than pie crusts, though? Pillsbury biscuits — and our recipe from our video producer Ali Rosen shows you how. 

Credit

Shutterstock.com

Slide Image
1. Allrecipe's World's Best Lasagna
Headline
1. Allrecipe's World's Best Lasagna
Description

Allrecipes.com’s "World’s Best Lasagna" recipe remained the number one recipe from the number one recipe website. While their sausage and ground beef variety looks pretty delicious, we like our healthier, gluten-free version. It’s packed with hearty vegetables that let you indulge and eat healthy.

Credit

Shutterstock.com