The Best Stand Mixer Per Consumer Reports Isn't KitchenAid

Add Daily Meal on Google:

We may receive a commission on purchases made from links.

KitchenAid has been the go-to brand for reliable stand mixers since it launched the first of its kind in 1919. These classic kitchen appliances are touted for standing the test of time, with some owners reporting theirs lasting 40 years. It's worth pointing out, though, that some users aren't happy with the modern improvements and have reported newer models breaking down in just five years. Now, even nonprofit consumer products tester Consumer Reports has replaced KitchenAid with luxury brand Smeg as its top pick for stand mixers.

Italian manufacturer Smeg was established in 1948 and became renowned for its line of premium major appliances before it launched a small kitchen appliance line in 2014. In Consumer Reports' lab testing, the Smeg Forte (SMF05, the newest model) scored top marks when it came to mixing egg whites, cakes, and whipped cream. It outperformed the runner-up — the KitchenAid Artisan Plus (KSM50) — in whipping cream. While the Forte also received the highest score possible in the noise category, it's worth noting that its performance in the categories of crepe batter, convenience, kneading, and mayonnaise was just short of perfection.

On top of that, you may pay a little less for the overall better performance of Smeg's Forte stand mixer — $549.95 at Amazon and Best Buy. The KitchenAid Artisan Plus has a retail price of $599.99. One day, it could even be among the high-end kitchen items you might find at HomeGoods and similar discount retailers.

The Smeg Forte stand mixer comes with more than powerful features and accessories

Part of the reason Consumer Reports found that the Smeg Forte outperformed the KitchenAid Artisan Plus overall could be attributed to the gap in motor power. While the Forte has a 750-watt direct-drive motor, the Artisan Plus only has a 350-watt motor. The Smeg SMF05 model comes with redesigned core accessories — a dough hook, flat beater, flex edge beater, and wire whisk, as well as a pouring shield (similar accessories to the KitchenAid). The designers worked to improve the appliance's stability and provide safer operation with a smooth start that gradually increases speed as well.

However, there's more to the Forte than its motor and accessories. It's the high-end Smeg stand mixer that adds a retro touch to any kitchen, too, with a 1950s style designed by Milan-based deepdesign. The Smeg Forte has earned several notable design awards, including the Good Design Award and the iF Design Award.

Praise for the Smeg Forte isn't coming only from industry experts. "It is as beautiful in person as I had imagined. There's nothing lacking. It's everything I wanted and needed. Even the packaging was exciting," one Amazon customer said. "It's way better than my old Kitchen Aid. All that and the color and design, make this my most favorite splurge of all time!!" Others like that the Forte models have a slightly smaller construction compared to KitchenAid. However, it's worth noting that a few customers preferred their KitchenAid stand mixers over the Smeg.