13 Fast Food BBQ Sauces, Ranked Worst To Best

Add Daily Meal on Google:

While ketchup is often the default go-to condiment for fast food, these days diners have a rainbow of options to add flavor to their fries, chicken, and burgers. One of America's most loved accompaniments for fast food and more is BBQ sauce, and no wonder — the condiment's combination of sweet, smoky, tangy, and sometimes spicy flavors brings a powerful kick to whatever it touches. Within the realm of BBQ sauce, there's quite a variety — though most fall into the sweet tomato-based American category — and that's reflected in the many styles on offer at fast food restaurants.

I'm an opinionated enthusiast of sauces and condiments of all kinds, and my curiosity in this area drove me to wonder how different options at major fast food chains stack up. After procuring containers of BBQ sauce from 13 restaurants, I put them to the test, dipping a selection of fries and chicken into each one and analyzing them. A good BBQ sauce should be packed with flavor and a balance of all elements, well seasoned but not too salty, and should complement (not clash) with traditional fast food items. With those criteria in mind, here's how I ranked these BBQ sauces, from worst to best.

13. Jack in the Box BBQ Sauce

I found nothing appealing about Jack in the Box's BBQ sauce. First, the texture: gelatinous, goopy, sticky, and way too thick. It looks like some kind of chocolate syrup, and it's just as sweet. That molasses-like sweetness is so overpowering that it buries whatever other flavors might exist somewhere in this sauce, with the exception of an element of smoke.

In an ideal world, some smokiness would bring welcome balance to the overabundance of sweetness, but that's unfortunately not the case here. Instead, the smoke is so artificial and acrid that it completely clashes with the sauce's sugary personality, and in the process creates a mishmash of unpleasant flavors. Jack in the Box does some things very well, like its fan-favorite curly fries — which are among the styles of fries you should definitely know about — however, it would be the very last place I'd go for anything involving BBQ sauce. Personally, I can't stand ketchup, but I'd prefer that condiment hands-down over whatever this stuff is.

12. Burger King BBQ Sauce

Burger King's BBQ sauce is similar in appearance and taste to the one from Jack in the Box, but it's slightly less offensively terrible, so it earns the second worst spot on this list. The sweetness here is still overpowering, but it has a more interesting flavor with a touch of fruitiness. There's an attempt at smokiness in the mid-palate, but the sweetness at the start and finish pretty much washes it out. At least it's not a particularly acrid smoke flavor, but it is underwhelming and fades quickly.

Not enough salt and not enough spice leave this sauce flat and one-dimensional. It adds almost nothing to food except for sugar and a somewhat slimy texture, neither of which are improvements to anything, even the worst fast food items. A sweet sauce needs another element — acidity, umami, spice, heat, anything — substantial enough to add balance, and this doesn't have it. 

11. Wienerschnitzel BBQ Sauce

What puts Wienerschnitzel's BBQ sauce one slot above the worst two in this ranking is its texture. It's similarly thick, but it has a richness to it rather than an just an oily gloopiness. I wish it had a better flavor to go along with its pleasing mouthfeel, but sadly it's yet another unbalanced, overly sweet condiment that's lacking in dimension.

A sauce that's this rich and luscious in texture needs to have bold and robust flavors to go along with that, but there's no intensity here. It's fruity up front, sugary in the middle, and saccharinely sweet on the finish. I detected a hint of black pepper, but rather than improving the sauce, it only made it seem more disappointing because there's not enough of it to make a difference. More pepper alone might not be enough to put this much higher up this list, but it would be a start. 

10. Sonic BBQ Sauce

The pros and cons of Sonic's BBQ sauce are nearly identical to those of Wienerschnitzel's. The only difference, really — which puts this one slightly ahead — is that it has a subtle smokiness to complement its sweetness, and it's a touch more savory. It's still too sweet and too flat, lacking any meaningful kind of spice, tang, or punch.

As I dipped into Sonic's sauce, I kept thinking that this is a BBQ sauce with training wheels. Everything except for the sweetness is muted, as if it's afraid to come on too strong. That's not what I want from BBQ sauce. I want something with power and pep and gusto. There's nothing wrong with subtlety and nuance, but it needs to be earned with quality and balance. With Sonic's sauce, it's obvious that's not the case. Like Wienerschnitzel, Sonic isn't bad when it comes to texture, but the flavor doesn't match up to its palate-coating richness. It's also lacking in salt.

9. McDonald's Tangy BBQ Sauce

The tangy BBQ sauce from McDonald's does live up to its name. Two types of vinegar, distilled and red wine, give it a bright, tart dimension that complements fatty, salty fast food quite well. This sauce has a decent amount of saltiness itself, which bridges its sweetness and tanginess nicely. That's all fine and good, but that's also pretty much it.

Sweetness and tanginess should always be present in BBQ sauce, but those two elements alone aren't enough to make it really sing. While McDonald's sauce does those two things well, I found myself looking for more — pepper, smoke, heat, I'd even settle for some warmth. I found none of that, at least not enough to meet the levels of sweet and sour flavors. While the texture isn't awful, it's right on the verge of being slick and gloopy. I wouldn't turn my nose up at McDonald's BBQ sauce, but I wouldn't go out of my way for it, either.

8. Chick-fil-A Classic Barbecue Sauce

Now with Chick-fil-A's barbecue sauce, we're getting somewhere. This condiment has a caramelized sweetness with more dimension than the previous sauces. Its tang is along the same lines as McDonald's, and it also includes hints of peppery heat. Because the sweet element of Chick-fil-A's sauce tastes deep and rich, the lack of any other substantial flavor components is less glaring. Even so, I wish there was stronger acidity and spice.

Chick-fil-A's sauce is lighter in texture and flavor than many of the other sauces, which makes sense as its primary companion is mildly flavored chicken and it doesn't have to stand up to something more intense like beef. That said, there are a few other chicken-centric fast food chains that boast more interesting and flavorful BBQ sauces, and they ranked higher, so there's clearly no need for restraint based purely on the type of protein. This sauce makes a perfectly serviceable condiment for chicken and fries, but it doesn't quite make anything pop. As far as Chick-fil-A sauces go, you're better off with any of the chain's other more exciting options.

7. Wendy's Honey BBQ Sauce

After tasting so many sauces that were overly sweet and lacking dimension, I dug into Wendy's Honey BBQ sauce with some hesitance. The fact that it advertises honey right on the package made me think it would be yet another cloying, unbalanced sauce less than a degree away from ketchup. That's not the case, thank goodness, as I'm always rooting for this particular fast food chain to do our shared name proud. While this sauce landed in the middle of the pack, it's got a lot to like.

Honey and smoke are the two dominant flavors, and they're both on equal footing in intensity, giving this sauce a well-balanced base. A vinegary tang binds those two elements together, enhanced by a good level of salt to amplify everything without going overboard. The viscosity is very much like honey and clings well to food. I found myself wishing for some pepper, some heat or spice of any kind, to come through, but other than that, Wendy's honey BBQ sauce is a pretty darn good sauce. 

6. Arby's Hickory Smoked BBQ Sauce

As a chain that's famous for its meats, Arby's should have one of the better BBQ sauces out there, and it's a pretty good one. I feel like I've given this sauce a bit of a disadvantage because I didn't try it with roast beef, which is Arby's claim to fame, but even with fries and chicken it serves its purpose admirably. Smoke and tang are the two main characteristics of this sauce, and both of those elements are pleasant and flavorful — not sour, not acrid, and well balanced with the sauce's sweetness.

There's a jelly-like gloopiness to the texture that's not particularly appealing, and a promise of peppery spice that fades before it comes to fruition. Other than those issues, this is a solid BBQ sauce. I wish it had more spice, and a less gelatinous texture, but the hickory smoke flavor is well done. I think this sauce is designed to be on something like a burger, rather than a plain french fry, but it works.

5. KFC Honey BBQ Sauce

I wasn't expecting to like the sweeter style BBQ sauces in this lineup as much as I did, but I realize now that's because I've had so many that are unbalanced. My distaste for ketchup likely springs from the same well. I don't want to dip fried chicken in high fructose corn syrup, but sign me up for a sauce that's sweetened with brown sugar and honey. KFC's Honey BBQ sauce manages to balance its sweetness well. 

Though this sauce didn't wow me with its slick, gelatinous texture, it did have a complex and pleasing savory dimension that worked really well with its rich sweetness. I wanted it to be a little lighter, tangier, zestier, spicier, something — but it's a well seasoned and flavorful sauce regardless. Honestly, I don't know if KFC's chicken needs this sauce, but it makes a great dip for fries. A little more smoke would be welcome.

4. Carl's Jr. Western Barbecue Sauce

As long as I have been a conscious human on this planet, I've associated Carl's Jr. with barbecue sauce. The chain's Western Bacon Cheeseburger, topped with onion rings and slathered in the stuff, was a staple of my teenage years. It wasn't until this project, however, that I'd really dug into the substance of Carl's Jr.'s BBQ sauce and analyzed it as its own entity. Turns out, it's great. From here on in this ranking, these are all top-tier sauces, so please understand that only minor issues keep this from being in the top three.

The texture of this sauce is creamy, rich, and lacks any weird gloppy jelly-like consistency. You can actually see flakes of black pepper in the sauce, and you can taste them. Smoke comes through in each bite without overpowering the other flavors, and the sweetness here acts as a balancing agent rather than the main event. It's tart and tangy on the finish, bringing you back for more. I can attest that this barbecue sauce is fantastic on a burger, but it's also delicious with chicken and fries. It's good stuff.

3. Five Guys BBQ Sauce

One of the great things about Five Guys is that they don't nickel and dime you when it comes to toppings and sauces. Of course, it's not the cheapest burger spot, but at least you won't do a double take when you look at your receipt if you're a sauce fanatic. Quite honestly, I felt like I was fleecing the joint a bit when I got a single order of fries and asked for multiple sides of BBQ sauce and they didn't charge me extra, but that's the Five Guys vibe.

Five Guys has spectacular fries, especially the Cajun spiced variety, and I must say that the restaurant's BBQ sauce matches that quality completely. Right up front you get sharp pepper, followed by a fruity pop of sweetness, a kick of heat, and finishing with a tangy zip and strong tamarind note. The texture is smooth and light despite being absolutely bursting with intense flavors. If someone put this sauce on a shoe, I'd eat it. There were a few other strong contenders that edged it out, but this would be a BBQ sauce I'd go out of my way for.

2. Popeyes BoldBQ Sauce

While plenty of sauces on this list had a viscous, molasses-like texture, none of them matched it up with flavor of the same intensity level — except for Popeyes. The name "BoldBQ" graces the labels on its packets, and it's apt and well-earned. There's nothing shy about this sauce, nothing tame, nothing nuanced or subtle or muted. It's most certainly bold. If it weren't balanced, that could backfire, but here it works.

Name what you'd want in a BBQ sauce and you'll find it here. Heat, sweetness, tang, smoke — those are givens. There's also a sharp freshly-cracked peppercorn flavor, along with a funkiness that made me think of ferments like fish sauce or even wine. So much is happening here that it made my head spin. Yet, somehow, it all balances out and doesn't overpower. The sweetness of this sauce acts as a mediator, bringing together all of the other wild and intense flavors that would careen out of control without it. The gap between second and first place in this ranking may come down to personal bias, I admit, but there was one element lacking in this sauce that the winner possessed in spades.

1. Shake Shack BBQ Sauce

Mustard. It's what the BBQ sauce from Shake Shack has that no other sauce does — although a few others have a slight mustardy tang, none of them go all-in. Shake Shack's sauce says let's take the mustard and run. My love for this sauce over the others does come down to personal preference, as all taste tests do to some degree, but even being as objective as possible, I don't think this contest is particularly close. 

Shake Shack's BBQ sauce hit every mark and won every category. It's tangy and then some, with a biting sharpness that's softened by just enough sweetness to comfort your palate without turning into candy. Savory notes are there for dimension and umami satisfaction, balanced by a mellow yet lingering heat. The texture is creamy, not oily or jelly-like. This sauce feels like a worthy gourmet addition to anything, not just fast food. I'd put this stuff on an expensive grilled steak and feel pretty good about it. No need to do that, though, as it's the perfect accompaniment to just about everything on Shake Shack's menu, including any of the chain's epic burgers.

Methodology

I visited 13 fast food restaurants in my area and ordered a side of either fries or chicken (nuggets or tenders, depending on the menu) along with sides of BBQ sauce. If a restaurant offered more than one style, I chose the most traditional option.

Once I had all of the sauces and sides, I got to tasting them. To start, I tasted each sauce with the side from the matching restaurant, but I also tried them with other restaurants' offerings to get a sense of the sauce's versatility. I looked for a balance of sweet and tangy, along with typical BBQ flavors from smoke and spice, and a good salt level. Texture was another major factor, as the sauce should be thick enough to work as a dip, but not so thick that it's unpleasantly gloopy. While I did rank the sauces against one another, I didn't compare them one-to-one in order to not give an advantage to a particular BBQ sauce style. I tried to judge each on its own merits and how well it expressed the style it was going for.