This Is Consumer Reports' Highest-Rated Dutch Oven Under $50
We may receive a commission on purchases made from links.
Dutch ovens are expensive. Most often made from cast iron coated in enamel, the cooking pots can last a lifetime if treated well. If the price point is too high, that's difficult to justify for an occasional braise. Fortunately, the nonprofit consumer advocacy group Consumer Reports rated some of the top Dutch ovens on the market and reviewed one that sells for under $50: Farberware Radiant Nonstick.
The Farberware Radiant Nonstick pot currently sells for around $37.79 on Amazon, making it the highest rated cheap option near the top of Consumer Reports' list. The pot earned a rating above some others recommended by the site's rundown, although it did not receive a recommendation itself (Consumer Reports did not explain why). Made with aluminum and a nonstick coating, it is not a traditional enameled cast-iron Dutch oven. The reviewers gave the pot perfect marks for bread baking, cooking evenness, and speed of heating, and high marks for ease of cleaning and sauce simmering. Since it's made with aluminum, the 5.5-quart pot weighs roughly only 2.5 pounds, far less than similarly sized Dutch ovens. Unlike others made from cast iron, which can handle 500 to 600 degrees Fahrenheit, the Farberware aluminum pot is only rated up to 350 degrees Fahrenheit in the oven. And, like with any metal pot, you still should never put this Dutch oven in the microwave.
What makes an aluminum Dutch oven different from one made of cast iron?
An aluminum Dutch oven like this one from Farberware works differently than one made from cast iron. Cast iron heats up slowly, but once hot, it takes a while to cool down. Aluminum is the opposite. You can get to cooking sooner, but it won't retain the heat and there may be some hot spots. You don't need to season aluminum pots and pans, so it's ready to go right away. Cleaning is easier — you can wash with soap and water and set to dry on the rack, as aluminum doesn't rust. If you have any particularly caked-on bits of food, use our tips on getting an aluminum pan looking as good as new.
The significantly lower weight of the aluminum Dutch oven is better for those looking for dishes that are easy to lift. Carrying a heavy pot full of hot liquid can be dangerous if you aren't prepared. Those cooking on a trail also appreciate the pounds saved with this Farberware version.
If you're looking for more traditional cast-iron Dutch ovens at an affordable price, Consumer Reports had some the site recommended even though they got lower ratings. Walmart sells the Mainstays 4.75 quart enameled cast-iron Dutch oven for $29.97. This style of Dutch oven is better for tasks like deep frying than an aluminum one with lighter walls and lid.