Seven Stellar New York Lobster Rolls Slideshow

Red Hook Lobster Pound

Red Hook Lobster Pound has been recognized as having one of the best lobster rolls in New York City. Located in Brooklyn, Red Hook serves up Maine-style lobster rolls every day for $16.You also can catch their food truck as it moves throughout the city.

Urban Lobster Shack

Urban Lobster Shack serves their lobster roll several ways: they offer a lobster tail roll, New England lobster roll, and a few other options, all served with coleslaw for less than $20.

Ed's Lobster Bar

At Ed’s Lobster Bar, lobster comes in many different shapes and forms, but the lobster roll is a winning option. The price is based on the market price of lobster, plus each roll is served with fries and a pickle. 


Luke's Lobster

Luke’s Lobster claims to have the most affordable lobster roll in New York City. The lobster roll alone is $15, and with beer, chips, and a pickle, it rings up as $20. If the price is price is not good enough, the quality is — the lobster is brought fresh from Maine daily.

Mermaid Inn

Yelp/Mermaid Inn

At Mermaid Inn they serve a lobster sandwich on a brioche bun with fries. This sandwich is reminiscent of a New England lobster roll and costs $26.

Pearl Oyster Bar

You cannot talk about lobster rolls without mentioning Pearl Oyster Bar. It was open in 1997 and has been serving up lobster rolls ever since.

Mary's Fish Camp

Mary’s Fish Camp serves everything from spicy chilled gazpacho with lobster knuckle to Ahi tuna melt with gruyere, but you simply cannot miss their lobster rolls served every day at market price.