Forget The Filet-O-Fish: 4 Fast Food Fish Sandwiches With Higher-Quality Ingredients
Burgers and chicken sandwiches are great, but sometimes you want a different choice of animal protein. Or perhaps you're a pescatarian and don't consume meat from land animals at all. Or maybe you just love seafood. In such instances, the fast food fish sandwich is a great option when you're on the road and looking for a bite. One of the most iconic sandwiches out there is the McDonald's Filet-O-Fish, a Lenten favorite that the Golden Arches has been serving up since 1962.
Made with a crispy patty of wild-caught Alaska pollock served with half a slice of American cheese and tartar sauce on a steamed bun, the Filet-O-Fish is a classic, but it hasn't changed much since its inception. Meanwhile, other fast food chains have taken the idea of a fried fish sandwich and run with it, improving on the menu item with higher-quality ingredients and preparation methods. The next time you're looking to change things up from the McDonald's staple, you might consider the offerings from one of the following chains.
Popeye's Flounder Fish Sandwich
Popeyes may be most famous as a Louisiana-style fried chicken chain, but when the brand turns its attention to fish, it brings the flavor there as well. Popeyes' Flounder Fish Sandwich is an occasional offering, usually appearing in the spring, and it's absolutely worth seeking out when it does. The titular flounder makes it a total standout in the space, with most brands opting for the more economical wild-caught pollock instead. But Popeyes' top-tier ingredients don't end there; it surrounds its fish with pickles (an acidic and textural upgrade from the Filet-O-Fish) and your choice of tartar sauce or a spicy sauce, served on a brioche bun.
And while you might have to wait until next spring to sample this sandwich, keep in mind that it's not the only seafood item Popeyes offers. The brand sells fried butterfly shrimp all year long as part of its permanent menu.
Culver's North Atlantic Cod Sandwich
Culver's is known for using high-quality ingredients and preparing them with care, and this trend certainly extends to the chain's fish sandwich. Known as the North Atlantic Cod Sandwich, it's another upgrade from the Filet-O-Fish in terms of the seafood being used. While both fish are flaky and tasty, cod is often more expensive than pollock and can be firmer and more flavorful.
As with the Filet-O-Fish, this sandwich comes with tartar sauce and cheese, but unlike McDonald's version, it swaps American cheese for shredded Wisconsin cheddar. Culver's tops it all off with some fresh lettuce and serves it on a buttered, toasted hoagie roll. Unlike some of the items on this list, this is a permanent menu item, so you can enjoy that satisfying mix of ingredients all year round — perhaps with a side of the chain's famous cheese curds or fried pickles.
Burger King Fiery Big Fish Sandwich
Unsurprisingly, Burger King has a fish sandwich of its own. In fact, the fast food chain known for letting you "have it your way" has two options for seafood lovers to choose from: the Big Fish Sandwich and the Fiery Big Fish Sandwich, with the latter available seasonally, usually around Lent. Both of these menu items feature an Alaska pollock fillet coated in panko and served with pickles, tartar sauce, and lettuce on a brioche bun (note that cheese does not come standard on these sandwiches, unlike some of the other entries on this list).
The Fiery version, however, takes the flavor profile to the next level by adding a spicy glaze into the mix. If you like fried fish sandwiches but feel that some of the standard options are a little on the humdrum side, the additional heat in BK's version is sure to be a benefit.
Wendy's Crispy Panko Fish Sandwich
The last entry on this list, Wendy's Crispy Panko Fish Sandwich, is a bit of a paradox. While it undeniably uses some higher-quality ingredients than McDonald's version, that doesn't necessarily make it a superior sandwich. This seasonal menu item is made from wild-caught pollock just like the Filet-O-Fish, but it is coated in crispy Panko instead of simply deep-fried, and adds a pickle, lettuce, and dill tartar sauce (upgrades from the Filet-O-Fish), served on what the brand calls a "premium bun."
However, despite the good-quality ingredients, not everyone is sold on this item, and it will often rank low on lists of fast food fish sandwiches. This disappointing outcome might be a symptom of some of the decisions from Wendy's corporate board — its CEO admitted to the Wall Street Journal that food quality had not been a top priority for the chain, vowing to rebuild the menu "at the ingredient level, at the item level, at the menu-category level." Hopefully this rebuilding will involve putting some more care into the Crispy Panko Fish Sandwich so it can live up to the potential of its premium ingredients.