10 Ways You’ve Been Cooking Backyard Burgers All Wrong

Flare-ups and flips, here are solutions to common burger barbecue problems
You’ve Been Cooking Backyard Burgers All Wrong

Shutterstock

10 Ways You’ve Been Cooking Backyard Burgers All Wrong

10 Ways You’ve Been Cooking Backyard Burgers All Wrong
istockphoto.com

It’s that time of year — the sun is out (most of the time), the weather is warming up, and you finally have a reason to roll the grill that has been gathering dust since last year out into your backyard or onto your fire escape (tsk tsk).

Perhaps you are a natural, making your own marinades and twirling your tongs like a pro. Maybe you can get your grill fired up on the first try, sans any lighting aids, creating a perfectly balanced landscape of both hot spots and cool upon which to grill all afternoon.

But then again, maybe not. Do you wake up in the night, fearful of grills that cannot be mastered? Do you worry about burnt burgers that are dry and tough? Do you gaze upon the grill with suspicion, wishing you knew how to master it? Well never fear! Read on for 10 solutions to common burger grilling mistakes and become the backyard chef you have always dreamed of being.

You’re Mixing the Meat Too Aggressively

You’re Mixing the Meat Too Aggressively
Shutterstock

Some people behave as though the ground beef destined to be hamburgers has personally affronted them, called their mother names, and pushed their kid sister in the mud for no reason. That is not the way to treat ground beef! The less you handle your burger meat the better. If you manhandle it, the proteins in the meat get all worked up, which causes your burgers to be less tender.

You’re Mixing Seasonings in Too Soon

You’re Mixing Seasonings in Too Soon
Shutterstock

It is important to remember that you’re making hamburgers, not meatloaf. Seeing hamburgers fully loaded with onion, herbs, or even an egg or two is more common than it ought to be. Minimalism is the name of the game. To make your burgers optimally savory, try to refrain from seasoning the meat at all — that is until right before it goes on the grill.

You’re Tempering Your Burgers

You’re Tempering Your Burgers
istockphoto.com

If you’re looking for a perfectly medium-rare burger, then go against your well-meaning but misguided intuition. Remember you are not cooking steaks! The best way to cook an average sized burger patty is straight from the fridge. By cooking from cold, you allow the burger the chance to develop a lovely crust while avoiding overcooking the middle. However, if you prefer overcooked burgers, then by all means temper away!

You’re Not Seasoning Liberally

You’re Not Seasoning Liberally
Shutterstock

Salting the burgers before they are formed into patties causes the muscle proteins to dissolve which will result in a patty that has a completely different texture — more like a sausage than a burger. But if you wisely choose not to mix salt into the burger itself, make sure you season liberally with salt and pepper just before going to the grill. Use more salt than you think you need. There’s a reason restaurant food tastes so good, and it has a lot to do with salt and how they season things before cooking. Seasonings should be liberally and evenly applied. You will achieve a more even layer by sprinkling from a height of about 6 inches.

Your Grill Is Too Hot or Too Cold

Your Grill Is Too Hot or Too Cold
Shutterstock

You need to grill at the correct temperature. Too hot and your burgers will burn on the outside and remain raw on the inside. Too cold and they will stick to the grill, dry out, and develop an unappetizing grey color inside and out. The best approach to grill heat is to have a hot zone (with more coals) and a cooler zone (with fewer coals) for more indirect heat. Start your burger in the hot zone to achieve a perfect crust and then move them to the cooler zone if they are developing too much color too quickly.

Your Grill Is Dirty

Your Grill Is Dirty
Shutterstock

Make sure your grill is clean before you start grilling. If the bars are clogged with crusty remains from last year’s barbecue, your grill is not going to cook efficiently at all. That nasty gunk is impeding the heat transfer between flame and food, which is definitely not what you want. So use some elbow grease and scrub that grill! Half an onion on a meat fork is a good way to clean the grill in most cases, but if the situation is dire, get out the wire brush and make your grill sparkle like new.

You’re Flipping Them Before They’re Ready

You’re Flipping Them Before They’re Ready
Shutterstock

While there are now many who dismiss the notion that burgers should be flipped only once during cooking, there’s no denying that flipping too early is a big no-no. Wait until the burger is ready to be flipped, has developed a crust, and is no longer sticking to the grill.

You’re Encouraging Flare-Ups

You’re Encouraging Flare-Ups
Shutterstock

Sure it may impress your guests to see you casually cook burgers amid bursts of flame, but it isn’t doing your burgers any good. Encouraging flames is essentially encouraging an acrid charcoal flavor, which definitely won’t impress your friends once they bite into your burgers.

You’re Pressing the Life Out of Your Patties

You’re Pressing the Life Out of Your Patties
Shutterstock

Like those who cause flare-ups, some people like to look flashy when grilling in their garden. Moving things constantly from one spot to another, flipping, and — most disastrously — pressing down on burgers with a spatula. What a travesty! When patties are flattened like that, any potential juiciness literally goes down the drain, forcibly removed by way of spatula interference, left to sizzle into vapor on a hot coal. So please, do not press your patties.

You’re Letting Cooked Burgers Rest Before Serving

You’re Letting Cooked Burgers Rest Before Serving
Shutterstock

Once again, burgers are not steaks! As soon as they are off the grill, they should be put on a bun and eaten. Because burgers are made of ground meat rather than intact muscle, the longer they sit, the more juices will run out (instead of being contained like in a steak), leading to a burger drier than desired. So hurry up and eat your burger! For fabulous burger inspiration, check out these new burgers that everybody is talking about.

More from The Daily Meal:

Best Steak Grilling Tips From the Pros

The 27 Absolute Best Grilled Fish and Shellfish Recipes

10 Grilling Tools Every Outdoor Cook Needs

How to Cook the Perfect Steak

The Perfect Burgers, Hot Dogs, Ribs, and More for Backyard Barbecues