The Rare Martha Stewart Pyrex Collection You Won't Find On Store Shelves

We may receive a commission on purchases made from links.

Pyrex has been at the forefront of glass kitchenware for ages; used by a number of celebrities including the illustrious Ina Garten, this brand has gained a considerable following over the years. Pyrex has been around for over a century – founded in 1915 – and it is still going strong. But while today's glass dishware is still prominent online and in stores, hunting for vintage Pyrex pieces have become something of a kitchen collector's hobby. 

One such sought-after line is lifestyle icon Martha Stewart's Kmart line of kitchenware, the Martha Stewart Everyday line. First created in the late 1990s and early 2000s, Stewart's collection included a specialized set of glass dishware — her partnership with Pyrex. From oven-safe kitchenware to casserole dishes, the Martha Stewart Everyday Pyrex collection introduced unique and functional pieces tailored specifically to Stewart's signature color palettes and classic hosting style.

Today, tracking down pieces from this specific collaboration has become a prime target for many vintage kitchenware collectors. While you will not find them on store shelves, items like the Martha Stewart Everyday ribbed green lidded casserole dishes or specialized glass measuring cups pop up sporadically on secondary marketplaces such as Ebay, Facebook Marketplace, and even Etsy. But if you're really lucky, chances are you will find some pieces at local thrift stores or garage and estate sales. Pricing for these nostalgic pieces generally remains quite accessible compared to more elusive 1950s Pyrex pieces, with dishes from this early 2000s collection usually ranging anywhere from around $9 to $36 depending on the item type and condition. Listings that include the original glass lids along with the dishware can sell for even more.

The primary reason these items are considered rare is not because they were originally produced in small quantities. Because these Martha Stewart Everyday pieces were sold exclusively at Kmart during a specific retail timespan, millions of pieces were bought for everyday use rather than preservation as limited edition items. Over the decades, pieces such as these have dwindled due to dishwasher fading, accidental drops, or were simply discarded during kitchen updates — making complete sets with intact branding increasingly hard to find.

For collectors and kitchen enthusiasts, scoring a piece from the Martha Stewart Everyday glassware line offers its new owners both '90s nostalgia as well as practical use for daily kitchen tasks. As Y2K trends continue to surge in popularity, these once overlooked grocery store-adjacent collaborations have become something of a collector's item; far from the dated dishware they once were. So next time you find a piece of retro Pyrex, check to see if you are holding a piece from this rare Martha Stewart collection. Having some trouble distinguishing if your second-hand glass dishware is made from the coveted long-lasting borosilicate glass? Read our coverage on the differences between Pyrex and PYREX labeling.