Avoid This Store-Bought Apple Pie With Dry, Bland Crust And Mushy Filling

Add Daily Meal on Google:

We may receive a commission on purchases made from links.

A wedge of homemade apple pie scattered with a crunchy layer of caramelized sugar is in a league of its own when it comes to nostalgic desserts. But if you haven't got the time to prepare one at home, the store-bought variety can definitely pass muster if you select a quality option and top it with a scoop of vanilla ice cream. We taste-tested six store-bought apple pies to curate our own ranking, but along with the yummy offerings we savored, there was one that you should definitely avoid: Walmart's Freshness Guaranteed apple pie.

Priced at $7.34 for a 10-inch pie, this dessert came in at the very bottom of the list and failed on two crucial points. Firstly, the pastry was dry and bland even though it had crimped edges and looked appealing at first sight. Yes, the crust was golden but the pastry lid fell apart upon slicing and the base stuck to the pan, making it tricky to remove. This is a big problem if you want to slice and serve the pie to dinner guests because it has to be portioned out messily with a spoon. Secondly, the apples were tart and mushy instead of being toothsome and deliciously sweet. The ingredients list does mention lemon juice concentrate, which could account for the tartness of the filling, however, this is a common addition in an apple pie recipe because the acid in the juice prevents the fruit from browning.

Walmart's Freshness Guaranteed apple pie has a horrible crust

Surprisingly, Freshness Guaranteed apple pie does have some positive reviews on the Walmart website, but they relate to its affordable price point and size. However, other shoppers are unhappy with its taste, quality, and texture. For instance, one shopper who gave the product a one-star review said, "I'm sorry to say, but this was the most horrible apple pie I've ever had. The apples are rubbery and the crust is horrible." Meanwhile another reviewer said, "This apple pie was terrible. It was way too sweet, more than half of the sliced apples were not baked enough, some raw." Other reviewers complained that the pie tasted like metal and was under-baked, while one shopper agreed with our findings that the crust had to be spooned out of the foil instead of sliced due to its poor consistency.

In our opinion, you'd be better off purchasing the best apple pie in our taste test, which was from Village PieMaker, because it had a homemade quality and comforting character. The pastry was buttery and flaky while the fruit filling was vibrant and bright with flavor. The only negative is that this product costs just under $15 a pop, which is more than double the cost of Walmart's Freshness Guaranteed offering.