8 Grilling Slip-Ups and How to Fix Them

Avoid common grilling mistakes with these easy tips

Grilling Out

One of grilling’s most appealing aspects is that it’s a quick and relatively low-maintenance way of cooking food — making a summer barbecue an easy way to feed a small or large group of friends. But this fantastic dinner can easily go awry if the cook doesn’t follow some basic grilling rules: Picture scorched eyebrows, blackened meat (not in the good way), or raw food all because of an empty propane tank.

Whether you’re a charcoal kind of griller or a gas die-hard, a professional flame-tamer or first-timer, mistakes happen. We've listed some of the more common ones below and then talked to the Food Network's Aaron McCargo and cookbook author Sam the Cooking Guy to come up with some quick fixes (and preventative measures) for every cookout slip-up. Feel free to share any tips or horror grilling stories with us below!

Mistake #1: Overly Charred Food (a.k.a. Burnt)

Burnt and badly blackened food does not make for happy diners. Since this can be the result of several mistakes, we’ve listed the solutions for the different scenarios below.

Fix 1: Flare-ups can happen to anyone, whether you’re a master griller or beginner, but there are a few things you can do to avoid ruining your food when sudden bursts of flame occur (usually when oil or excess fat drips through the grates).  

A: Have a safe, cool spot on your grill that you can move food to when it happens.

B: Have a small fire extinguisher or spray bottle of water handy, whether it’s a fancy one or a homemade one. If grilling cookbook author Sam Zien doesn’t have a store-bought bottle, he pokes a hole in a water bottle and uses that to extinguish the flame. “It’s a fire right? Flare-ups happen, and it helps to bring flavor,” says Zien, but make sure it doesn't burn your food. (Photo courtesy of Corbis/Ocean)

C: If using an oil-based marinade, try to let excess marinade drip off the meat before placing it on the grill to avoid instigating a flare-up.

Fix 2: If the outside of a large piece of meat like brisket, pork butt, or a whole turkey is starting to burn before it’s close to being done, then, as the Food Network host Aaron McCargo recommends, you can take it off the heat and finish it low and slow in the oven. It will still have that smokiness and nice char without being overly burnt on the outside.

Fix 3: Don't apply sweet and sugary-based marinades like BBQ sauce throughout the grilling process. Just brush the sauce on during the last five minutes or so of cooking because it will burn otherwise, and you’ll lose all that delicious flavor you were trying to add.

Mistake #2: Food Sticking to the Grill

Fix: To avoid leaving pieces of fish and meat clinging to your grill, make sure to oil it well once it’s hot and ready to go. 

Mistake #3: Running Out of Coals or Propane

Fix: For gas grills, make certain you turn off the tank after use. For Zien, this often happens when he cleans the grill afterward. He explains that you have two choices when it comes to cleaning: You can either do it after you cook by cranking up the heat and letting all of the sticky stuff burn off the grill grates or do it 15 minutes before the next time you grill as you heat up your barbecue.

The problem is that more than once he’s gone to eat dinner and totally forgotten to turn off the grill causing him to run out of propane. Since you need a grill to be super-hot before you start cooking any way, why not wait until the next time you grill to clean it off? As he says, “I’m doing two things at once, burning off the foods while heating up the grill and saving time. I learned to compensate for my forgetfulness.”

For charcoal grills, it’s a good idea to have back-up coals ready, and using a charcoal chimney can help maximize the heat generated by the lit coals. Also, regularly test the heat of the grill by holding your hand over the grill, so you know when to add more. General rule of thumb: If you can only hold your hand over the grill for two seconds then it’s hot, three seconds then medium-high heat, etc. (Photo courtesy of Corbis/MM Productions)