6 Frozen Desserts To Buy At Aldi And 6 You Might Want To Avoid

Aldi has long been known as the champion of budget-savvy shoppers, offering quality grocery items at prices that have competitors scratching their heads. But as any seasoned Aldi shopper will tell you, the frozen dessert section can be a bit of a mixed bag. We've all experienced the disappointment of searching the frozen dessert aisle for a new late-night treat, only to find nothing but letdowns.

In this guide, we're here to help you navigate the icy shelves of Aldi's frozen dessert selection, spend less time and money on duds and more on indulging your favorite frozen treat cravings. Whether you're in the mood for a creamy ice cream, a delicious cold pie, or a refreshing, fruity popsicle to cool down on a scorching summer day, we've got you covered.

Grab your spoon and prepare your taste buds, because we're about to explore six of the finest and six of the less appealing frozen desserts you can snag at Aldi. 

Let's talk about a frozen dessert that might initially catch your eye, especially if you're a die-hard Oreo cookie fan. These Sundae Shoppe Vanilla Minis Ice Cream Cookie Sandwiches may seem like a sweet revelation for Oreo enthusiasts, but unfortunately, it leaves a lot to be desired and doesn't live up to expectations. 

First and foremost, let's address the size. When you look at the packaging, you might expect these sandwiches to align with your average, satisfyingly substantial ice cream sandwich. Unfortunately, it's nowhere close. In fact, it's essentially bite-sized, roughly the same dimensions as a regular Oreo cookie. It's a little thicker than the average Oreo due to the more substantial ice cream filling, but not by much. This pint-sized portion might leave you feeling a tad disappointed, especially if you were expecting a more substantial treat for your money.

Then there's the flavor, which is a bit of a mixed bag but not good enough to recommend. The chocolate cookie exterior is very chocolatey and delivers that familiar Oreo cookie flavor. However, the vanilla ice cream flavor doesn't taste like anything, much less the deliciously creamy Oreo filling you might expect. All in all, you may want to give these treats a pass and find something with a little bit better value.

These Specially Selected macarons at Aldi may look like a delightful treat, with a colorful appearance and delicate packaging, but it might not quite hit the sweet spot for everyone. Macarons have a reputation for being a more refined, indulgent dessert, and if you're on the hunt for macarons that'll truly wow your taste buds, these might not be your top pick. Sure, it looks lovely and all, but some texture and size factors must be considered. You might want to explore other dessert options that'll really hit the spot if you're seeking a more satisfying, sweet experience.

First off, these macarons are made with almond flour. While there's nothing necessarily wrong with almond flour in general, it can lead to a slightly different texture than you might be used to in your typical macaron. Some reviewers have found that these macarons are coarse, which isn't what you'd expect from this classic treat. You see, macarons are known for the melt-in-your-mouth quality, and these miss the mark on that front.

Then there's the size problem. You'd likely hope for a satisfying and indulgent bite when you pick up a box of macarons, especially considering the price tag. Unfortunately, these macarons are somewhat smaller than your typical macaron. So, you might find yourself wanting a bit more in each bite, and it feels like you're not getting enough value for your money.

The growing trend of keto-friendly products in recent years has brought about an array of options for health-conscious consumers, and Aldi is no exception. You'll find Sundae Shoppe Keto Ice Cream Cookie Dough among these options. Before giving in to your cravings, some aspects of this ice cream might not make it your first choice. 

First off, while it's designed to be keto-friendly, the flavor and texture are not quite what you'd expect in ice cream. Traditional ice cream delights us with its creamy richness, but keto-friendly ice creams often have to use different ingredients, like sugar substitutes. This can sometimes result in a flavor and texture that's not unpleasant but very different; some may miss that sweet, creamy familiarity. Overall, reviewers found this ice cream underwhelming. 

But the most significant consideration for keto-conscious shoppers is the serving size. If you follow a keto lifestyle, then you're certainly considering your net carb count. Sundae Shoppe Keto Ice Cream Cookie Dough comes in pint-sized containers, but here's the catch: Unlike brands like Halo Top that advertise the net carbs for the entire pint, the suggested serving size is just ⅓ of the pint. 

In other words, your portion is significantly smaller than you might expect. If you're used to indulging in a full pint of ice cream, it might not keep your dessert cravings at bay if you're watching your carbs.

This one may be a bit controversial to some Aldi shoppers out there, but we're not recommending that you steer clear of the entire Sundae Shoppe gelato series. Aldi is known for offering a variety of delightful frozen treats, and the gelato lineup does have its shining stars, like the Pistachio Biscotti and Triple Chocolate versions. However, when compared to other frozen desserts, some flavors can be a bit hit-or-miss, and the Sundae Shoppe Gelato Caramel Cookie Crunch is a miss.

The name itself may sound alluring and may make you imagine creamy gelato infused with rich caramel and studded with cookie crunch. Unfortunately, the reality falls short. The key letdown here is the flavor profile. While it's not necessarily a disaster, it's nowhere near as good compared to some of the other flavors in the Gelato lineup. The caramel might not be as luscious, and the cookie crunch may not deliver that satisfying texture you'd expect.

If you're eager to explore the world of Sundae Shoppe gelato at Aldi, it's best to steer clear of the Caramel Cookie Crunch flavor. Gelato should be a luxurious and indulgent experience, and there are flavors within this series that do a much better job of hitting those sweet spots.

At first glance, Aldi's Specially Selected frozen mini cream puffs may look like a convenient and delicious dessert option for parties, get-togethers, and celebrations. A large tub contains about 50 mini pastries you can defrost and serve for an after-dinner treat. However, a closer look at these petite pastries, and you may begin to have second thoughts.

First and foremost, the hallmark of cream puffs is their delicate, flaky pastry shells that effortlessly give way to rich and creamy fillings. Unfortunately, Specially Selected Mini Cream Puffs have texture issues. These mini cream puffs, in their frozen state, can be particularly stubborn when it comes to defrosting. 

Reviewers have often noted that the thawing process can take quite a while, even up to hours. To make matters worse, defrosting can sometimes lead to unintended consequences such as inconsistent thawing and sogginess. Few things are as disappointing as a cream puff that has gone limp due to thawing, and this texture problem can be a deal-breaker for those who value the puff's signature crispness.

The idea of a delicious dessert conveniently packaged in a jar sounds like a dream come true. However, JarJoy's products may be some of the more disliked frozen desserts that Aldi offers. One of the primary concerns raised by consumers is the quality and taste of JarJoy's desserts. Instead of a richly creamy and satisfying mouthfeel, many consumers have complained that the desserts are gritty and coarse. 

Size is another issue frequently raised by those who've tried this dessert. The jar's small 3.2 oz size often leaves consumers wanting more, and they might find it difficult to justify the price for the quantity provided.

It's important to note that JarJoy's Dessert in a Jar is typically found in the refrigerated sections of stores. However, in Aldi, it's typically located in the frozen section. This positioning can impact the way consumers perceive the product, as they might expect a different taste and texture experience from a frozen dessert compared to a refrigerated one.