Teen Chef Opens His First Restaurant with $160 Tasting Menu, Sparks Anger in Chef Community

Flynn McGarry, the teenage culinary prodigy, is finally opening up a restaurant, and one dish is a fancy peanut butter and jelly

Twitter c/o Flynn McGarry

The young chef and lamb saddle cooked on the bone with black olive, Meyer lemon, and a potato cooked in yogurt.

New York City is getting another high-end restaurant that will most likely be very difficult to snag a reservation for. But it’s not another Torrisi eatery, nor is it from Thomas Keller or Daniel Boulud. Actually, the chef is quite a bit younger: Flynn McGarry, the teenage chef hailed as a gastronomic prodigy, will open his first-ever full-fledged restaurant this month.

Two years ago, at the age of 14, McGarry ran a temporary pop-up restaurant, and now he’s going full-time. He will open Eureka at Creative Edge September 12 in the West Village, according to Food & Wine magazine.

Three days a week, McGarry will cook a $160, 14-course tasting menu featuring one of his signature dishes: an upscale peanut butter and jelly sandwich. It consists of peanut Ritz crackers with foie gras terrine and sour cherry compote, a reflection, perhaps of the chef’s tender age and impressive skills. Diners can also enjoy sea-water-brined sea urchin with carrot crémeux and coffee-pickled carrots.

We know one chef won’t be attending: David Santos, whose restaurant Louro closed its doors earlier this summer, posted an incendiary rant on Instagram, ripping into the young chef:

“The fact the media even calls him a chef offends me to no end….. [being a chef] is not about playing dress up and plating a couple dishes.”

Related Stories
Rachael Ray and Guy Fieri Now Mentoring Kid Chefs and More NewsFive S. Pellegrino Young Chef Judges On How to Break Into the Industry in Round Table VideoNBC Buys Teen Chef ComedyTips for Cooking with Kids10 Most Famous Kid Critics and Cooks

If you want to experience Eureka yourself, despite the criticism, you can try to snag yourself a ticketed reservation on the restaurant’s website.