11 Healthiest and Unhealthiest Frozen Pizzas (Slideshow)

You’ll be shocked to learn which frozen pizza is the healthiest of these options

11. DiGiorno Original Rising Crust Pizza

Jane Bruce

Just one little slice of this frozen pizza and you’ve already committed to a quarter of your calorie intake for the day. And everyone knows just one slice of pizza never cuts it.

Serving Size: 1/6 Pizza
Total Servings: 6
320 calories per serving

1,020 calories per package

10 grams total fat

10. America’s Choice Original Pizza

Jane Bruce

Ah, while there is no denying that America loves pizza, we aren’t so sure this should be your choice. Checking in at 720 calories, this “personal” pizza makes for one of the unhealthiest frozen pizzas on the list.

Serving Size: 1 Pizza

Total Servings: 1

360 calories per serving

720 calories per package

14 grams total fat

9. Tombstone Original Pizza

Jane Bruce

What’s on your Tombstone? We aren’t sure, but if you keep eating these little pizzas you may have a tombstone of your very own soon enough for us to find out! This frozen pizza is small enough to be tempting to eat by itself in one sitting, but with double the fat and calories this little pizza could cause a big problem for you later.

Serving Size: 1/2 Pizza
Total Servings: 2

380 calories per serving

760 calories per package
16 grams total fat

8. 365 Three Cheese Mini Pizzas

Jane Bruce

Surprisingly, these mini bites from Whole Foods aren’t exactly a wholesome pizza option. Though you do get to indulge in a lot of mini bites for the calorie count, you can’t ignore the fact that when it comes to pizza, you’re likely to polish it off.

Serving Size: 7 Pizzas
Total Servings: 2

340 calories per serving

680 calories per package

14 grams total fat 

7. Celeste Personal Pizza

Jane Bruce

Though this personal pizza isn’t too sinful, it still contains a ton of calories and a large amount of total fat. The reason why it isn’t super high on the unhealthy side of this list is because at least when you prep this pizza, you won’t go back for seconds!

Serving Size: 1 Pizza
Total Servings: 1 Pizza

320 calories per serving/per package
14 grams total fat

6. Trader Giotto’s Handmade 4 Formaggi

Jane Bruce

Trader Joe’s Italian cousin Trader Giotto makes a pretty impressive homemade pizza. We dig how its fat is a lot lower than some of its frozen competitors. Plus you can eat 1/3 of the pizza, and not over do it!

Serving Size: 1/3 Pizza

Total Servings: 3

310 calories per serving

930 calories per package

9 grams total fat

5. American Flatbread Tomato Sauce & Three Cheese

Jane Bruce

Its flatbread crust definitely gives it the advantage health-wise! You could enjoy this crispy frozen pizza at half the calories of a full dough one, but be warned, indulging in the whole thing will cost you 600 calories for the day.

Serving Size: 1/2 Pizza
Total Servings: 2
300 calories per serving

600 calories per package

10 grams total fat

4. Newman’s Own Margherita Pizza

Jane Bruce

A fresh tasting frozen pizza with a low calorie count to boot? Sign us up. While it is a little bit higher in total fat than we would like, this frozen pizza gives you the best bang for your caloric buck with only 280 calories for 1/3 of this pizza!

Serving Size: 1/3 Pizza
Total Servings: 3

280 calories per serving

840 calories per package

12 grams total fat

3. Whole Foods 12-inch Cheese Pizza

Jane Bruce

Made from fresh ingredients in the Whole Foods kitchens, these pizzas are take-out sized and fairly hearty. Two slices will only add up to 280 calories, and despite the entire pie being high on the calorie end, it remains relatively low in total fat.

Serving Size: 2 Slices
Total Servings: 6
280 calories per serving

1,680 calories per package

7 grams total fat

2. Amy’s 4 Cheese Pizza

Jane Bruce

Amy’s products are a favorite amongst natural and organic eaters and it isn’t hard to see why. These fresher ingredients lead to less calories per serving that any of its competition, though high on the total fat side.

Serving Size: 1/3 Pizza
Total Servings: 3

260 calories per serving

780 calories per package

14 grams total fat

1. Ellio’s Cheese Pizza

Jane Bruce

Surprisingly, this classic kid-favorite pizza is on the less sinful side of the frozen pizza spectrum. With two hearty (albeit square) slices you can enjoy a big lunch without completely derailing your day!

Serving Size: 2 Slices
Total Servings: 2.5
240 calories per serving

480 calories per package

5 grams total fat