Bonnie’s Grill Serves the Best Buffalo Wings in New York City

On our list of the 25 best Buffalo wings in America, Bonnie’s Grill was recognized as serving the very best in New York City

The Buffalo wings at Bonnie’s Grill in Brooklyn were named the fourth-best Buffalo wings in the country.

As legend has it, on the evening of March 4, 1964, Dominic Bellissimo was tending bar at the famed Anchor Bar in Buffalo, N.Y. with his mother Teressa in the kitchen. When a group of his hungry friends showed up, Dominic asked Teressa to whip up some food for them, so she took some chicken wings, which were intended to go into the stockpot, and instead tossed them in the deep fryer. She concocted a simple butter and hot sauce-based sauce, mixed them together, and arguably the greatest bar food of all time was born.

While you might argue that it’s impossible to judge a Buffalo wing because they’re all the same (just deep-fried wings tossed in sauce, right?), that couldn’t be further from the truth. A perfect Buffalo wing is crisp and not soggy in the least, completely coated in sauce but not bogged down by it, fresh from the fryer, crispy on the outside (with no flabby skin) while remaining juicy on the inside, and the sauce needs to have the right balance of spice to butter without being overly greasy. It’s actually a lot harder than it appears to make a perfect Buffalo wing, but the bars and restaurants honored on our list have got it down to a science. 

From humble sports bars to one of the country’s most well-known experimental restaurants, we tracked down the finest examples of the form, nationwide (we left out the big chains like Buffalo Wild Wings to give everyone their fair shake). The Buffalo wing is one of the most easily accessible, enjoyable, fun foods known to Americans, and is served just about everywhere that has a modest kitchen and a game on the TV and as it turns out, some of the very best in the country are served in New York City.

Located in the heart of Park Slope (a.k.a. Brooklyn’s Restaurant Row), the diminutive Bonnie’s, run by two guys from Buffalo, N.Y., is mostly taken up by a long counter from which you can watch your never-frozen wings fry to order, then get a toss in house-made Buffalo sauces of varying intensity. No garlic barbecue sauces here, just a near-flawless, Buffalo-style wing sauce. They're served steaming hot with just the right amount of sauce and are best washed down with one of their rotating craft beers or a cheap can of Genesee — there’s no better way to while away a lazy afternoon. The wings at Bonnie’s are so good, they came in at #4 on our list of the 25 best in America, beating out local competitors, Wogies (#24), meaning that Bonnie’s can also boast that they serve the very best Buffalo wings in The Big Apple.

Related Links
America's 25 Best Buffalo WingsExperts Agree: Los Tacos No. 1 is the Best Mexican Restaurant in New York CityXi’An Famous Foods Named the Best Chinese Takeout in New York CityHere’s the Best Burrito in New York CityDel Posto Voted the Best Italian Restaurant in New York and America