13 Best Bottled Milkshake Brands Ranked

Although Hershey's bottled milkshake is at the bottom of the list, you will find some positive reviews out there with consumers describing how delicious and creamy it is. This milkshake is a wallet-friendly treat that gives you 13 grams of protein and other nutrients, including calcium, iron, and potassium. It's also Kosher and made using low-fat milk.

However, the problem with Hershey's bottled milkshake is that it's way too sweet for some people. One serving of this drink has a whopping 51 grams of sugar; this is equivalent to more than 10 teaspoons, which is excessive for the average person. The American Heart Association strongly recommends that men keep their daily sugar consumption under 9 teaspoons, while the limit for women is six teaspoons per day. Hershey's milkshakes also contain artificial flavoring, so they might not be the healthiest drink to throw back every day.

Premier Protein is the way to go if you love your milkshakes in interesting flavors, like cafe latte, peanut butter, cake batter, pumpkin spice, and winter mint chocolate. This brand also has standard chocolate, strawberries & cream, vanilla, and caramel milkshakes. It's a great way to energize before or after a gym session, as these milkshakes provide up to 30 grams of protein. 

One athletic consumer describes these drinks as having "enough protein, not a lot of sugar, and not too many calories." According to the Mayo Clinic, consuming enough protein helps your body build strong muscles and repair damaged tissues. These tasty milkshakes from Premier Protein also get praise from consumers for providing 24 vital vitamins and minerals that support overall health and immunity, including folic acid, vitamin A, zinc, vitamin C, magnesium, vitamin K, calcium, and iron. 

But there are some complaints from reviewers about this product, which is why it has a low place on this list. Premier Protein has artificial flavors and sweeteners, so it's not the best-tasting drink you can buy. One reviewer from Target commented that it has an "Overwhelming taste of sucralose. If you are used to consuming sucralose, this is likely not a big deal."

Barebells milkshake is a yummy beverage that will fill you up without making you sluggish. Each 330-milliliter bottle gives you 24 grams of protein plus 12 grams of carbohydrates for that extra burst of energy, but because it has no added sugar, you won't experience a crash afterward. One Amazon reviewer shares their experience with Barebells protein shakes, saying, "I'm loyal to Barbells, drinks they are the only brand that when I drink their shakes it doesn't feel like drinking protein."

We appreciate that Barebells makes an effort to include different dietary restrictions. These milkshakes are gluten and lactose-free, making them easier on the gut. A thrilled user on Amazon wrote, "Delicious and lactose free can't go wrong with it!" Another buyer shared, "I love these shakes! So hard to find a no added sugar protein shake which actually tastes good. It tastes like a delicious chocolate milkshake. I have as an afternoon treat as I don't have enough protein in my diet. It's cleaner than other protein products and doesn't cause any tummy issues like some."

The only thing keeping Barebells milkshakes from claiming a higher place on this list despite these positive reviews is that it has the artificial sweeteners acesulfame-K and sucralose. Harvard Health explains that artificial sugar substitutes are linked to a higher risk of heart disease.

We love a simple, tasty treat for kids, and Happy Monkey milkshakes fulfill that need. This vegan milkshake is unlike other beverages for children that contain more chemical additives than nutrients as it's made from four to five simple ingredients and doesn't have fillers. It's delicious, the kids love it, and it has zero alternative sweeteners. 

A 100-milliliter portion of this drink provides 3.3 to 3.5 grams of protein for sustainable energy. Other vital nutrients that Happy Monkey milkshakes supply are calcium for bone development and vitamin B for overall health. Unfortunately, the amount of sugar it contains is concerning, with 7.7 to 8.9 grams in 100 milliliters. 

The small 200-milliliter packs of Happy Monkey milkshakes, which are only available in two simple flavors, strawberry and chocolate, can easily fit into your kid's lunch box or be served as a chilled snack on a hot day. 

If you hate the artificial taste of chemical sweeteners, then you'll love Bolthouse Farms milkshakes. One consumer happily reported, "It's great a drink especially when trying to add more protein into my diet. I'm allergic to "fake" sugars and most others have sucralose in them. This has cane sugar. It may be more calories than the other shakes but I don't get headaches from drinking it. It taste [sic] great too."

Despite having up to 38 grams of sugar per serving, Bolthouse Farms milkshakes don't have an overpowering sweet taste. But they also don't have that chalky taste of protein shakes even though they contain 18 to 30 grams of protein. This gives you long-lasting energy, so many consumers have named it their "favorite of all the protein shakes." 

This brand of bottled milkshakes gives you over 20 micronutrients, including vitamin B, calcium, iron, vitamin D, and zinc, making it an excellent way to support your diet. The main ingredients in Bolthouse Farms shakes are natural fruit extracts and reduced-fat milk. The Protein Plus drink from this company also includes whey and soy protein for added nutrition. These products are Kosher and free from preservatives.

Shaken Udder bottled milkshakes will have you feeling like you're seated in your favorite diner. They're thick, creamy, and flavorful, and one consumer said it's "easily the best chocolate milk available in stores." It's made with natural ingredients and is free from chemical additives like color, preservatives, or flavors. Another shopper on Amazon raved about the vanilla flavor, saying, "I love Shaken Udder so much. It's thicker than other milkshakes available and the taste is unbeatable. A true vanilla milkshake that is almost addictive." This natural taste and flavor are why it's among the top three bottled milkshake brands you can find.

As you enjoy the rich flavor of your Shaken Udder milkshake, beware because it's not a low-sugar beverage. Each 100-milliliter serving of the Chocoslush flavor contains 11.2 grams of sugar. The redeeming quality of this brand is that it's also rich in protein (3.6 grams), calcium, vitamin B, and other essential nutrients.

Shaken Udder also makes a vegan-friendly alternative called Shaken Other, which contains coconut milk. Even this plant-based option has won the hearts of consumers, with one person saying it "is just delicious you wouldn't know it was dairy free. Thick and creamy and tastes like a real treat."

Orgain makes such high-quality milkshakes it's hard to believe they're in a bottle. This brand is the clear winner because its products are made using organic milk obtained from purely grass-fed cows. According to a study published in Foods journal, the pasture diet helps cows produce healthier milk rich in protein and healthy fats, such as omega-3 and 6 fatty acids. 

Drinking these nutritional shakes from Orgain is a delicious way to add 16 extra grams of protein to your diet. It has only 11 grams of added sugars but no artificial sweeteners. Therefore, one consumer said these shakes have the "best taste ever." Plus, it's "easy to drink" and has "no after taste." Another reviewer wrote that Orgain milkshakes are "great for people who don't like 'fake' tasting chocolate shakes." This reviewer further describes its texture and taste saying, "no watery consistency and no fake sugar taste. Works great for me for an afternoon get-over-the-hump boost."

These products don't have soy or gluten, so they suit people with diverse nutrition needs or food sensitivities. The company also makes vegan protein shakes for kids and adults. Orgain shakes are non-GMO and Kosher certified and do a great job satisfying the taste and nutritional expectations of most buyers.