Top 10 North Fork Wines

Long Island wines to try now

The majority of Merlot I tasted on this trip was from 2005 and 2007, with both vintages considered to be excellent. The 2005s showed a balanced evolution of structure and fruit. Most are able to start drinking now, but many have the potential to age in your cellars. Another positive development in the region is how many wineries are starting to hold these bottles, so that the consumer can buy a wine ready to drink (such as 2005). That's not to say that the 2007s are structured beasts with unyielding pleasure — quite the opposite. Most of the 2007s I tasted were stylistically different, going for a riper style that remained fresh and vibrant on the palate. It's truly exciting to think where this is all going, but one thing's for certain; Merlot is here to stay on the North Fork.

However, Long Island doesn't begin and end with red wine. In fact, the white wines of Long Island have long been a strong point of the area, and the 2010 vintage really knocked it out of the park. These wines were perfectly ripe, but with lots of acidity and secondary aromas and flavors. Sauvignon Blanc, in particular, seems to have really come to age; most were very good and some were simply excellent. Many vintners continue to make a number of Chardonnay bottlings. Chardonnay has gained the reputation of being a blank canvas in which a winemaker can build upon. And if that's the case, then I have to say that most of the Long Island winemakers I visited with are doing a fine job at it from simple sippers that would be great at poolside, to big, layered barrel-fermented giants that can be enjoyed with or without a meal. Lastly, I would be remiss not to mention the handful of seriously good Gewürztraminer tasted on my trip.

2010 in general was an excellent vintage that played right into the hands of most winemakers. The question wasn't whether the fruit would achieve ripeness early enough to pick. The question was, how soon should we pick to avoid overripe grapes? Kareem Massoud of Paumanok Vineyards stated, "Some wineries were picking Champagne grapes as early as August." For the whites, it was a race to the finish. However, for the reds, it was the leisure of picking when winemakers wanted to. The 2010 reds, from what I tasted from barrel at Lenz, were voluptuous, with broad structure, intense focused fruit and truly seductive.

It's very exciting to think about where Long Island is going as a wine region, and I can tell you that it's been placed firmly on my map.


Click here for the Top 10 North Fork Wines Slideshow.

—Eric Guido