Lagunitas Drops IPA Label Lawsuit Against Sierra Nevada After Social Media Backlash
As we've previously reported, American breweries have been accidentally infringing on each other's beer names and design elements left and right, and often having to settle the matter through legal channels. In 2013, for instance, Lagunitas Brewing Co. ceded the numbers "420" on many of its bottles to SweetWater Brewing Co., which had been brewing 420 Extra Pale Ale for two decades.
Recently, Lagunitas itself launched a trademark infringement lawsuit against Sierra Nevada, claiming that the label of Sierra Nevada's Hop Hunter IPA too closely resembled Lagunitas' flagship IPA.
"The unique "IPA" lettering used in the Lagunitas "IPA" Family of Trademarks has a distinctive serif font, distinctive kerning (or letter spacing), between the "P" and the "A", slightly aged or weathered look, with uneven areas on each of the letters, and the elimination of any periods between the letters. These elements together are unique to the iconic design of the Lagunitas IPA."
Lagunitas' founder Tony Magee argued that Sierra Nevada's label would potentially suggest a collaboration between the two companies when there was none, or otherwise harm the Lagunitas brand.
However, following backlash from several consumers on Twitter,where Magee had been chronicling some of the lawsuit proceedings:
Lagunitas didn't do themselves any favors. They need to focus on what they are good at: making beer.
— Jordan Crouse (@CosmicPenguin) January 14, 2015
So @lagunitasbeer is in a twist over @SierraNevada and a faintly similar font on a label. Guess I've bought my last Lagunitas beer.
— Bob (@Khazhad) January 14, 2015
Whoa this is frustrating because I love both breweries. Seems catty; I feel the designs are different enough. http://t.co/nVRVjSVQ4m
— Tori (@stttories) January 14, 2015
the company founder later announced that he had opted to drop the suit, admitting that he had been "seriously schooled" and understood that many of his customers did not support the suit.
Defending a biz requires answers to Hard Questions. Q's like: Are our Foundations Strong? Are our Flavors right? Are our Labels Defensible?
— LagunitasT (@lagunitasT) January 14, 2015
There r many Courts in the world. For me, over the last month, one Court was a series of rebuffed phone calls. Another was a court of law...
— LagunitasT (@lagunitasT) January 14, 2015
Today was in the hands of the ultimate court; The Court of Public Opinion and in it I got an answer to my Question; Our IPA's TM has limits.
— LagunitasT (@lagunitasT) January 14, 2015
I don't know every answer beforehand, so I feel around for the edges and try to learn. Today I was seriously schooled & I heard you well...
— LagunitasT (@lagunitasT) January 14, 2015
Tomorrow mornin we'll Drop the Infringement Suit & get back to answering other Questions. I don't think I was wrong for wanting to know cuz...
— LagunitasT (@lagunitasT) January 14, 2015
I had to know the Answer, but the Answer came much sooner than I thought and in a different Court than I thought it would. Can I say thanks?
— LagunitasT (@lagunitasT) January 14, 2015