Alchemy - Edgartown

American, Seafood
$ $ $ $
71 Main St (Church St)
Edgartown, MA 02539
(508) 627-9999
5:30pm - 10:00pm
5:30pm - 10:00pm
5:30pm - 10:00pm
5:30pm - 10:00pm
5:30pm - 10:00pm
10:30am - 2:30pm



  • Great places for drinks!
  • Try an expresso martini in the upstairs back bar
  • Ginger gimlet and the truffled fries with duck confit
  • At this bi-level restaurant and bar, the steak frites and fried risotto balls dont distract from the tropical drinks such as tangy mojitos and gin-and-juices.
  • Rosemary breaded swordfish was amazing! Also try the clam/sausage appetizer.
  • The Patio Punch cocktail is a MUST.
  • Everything since Craig Decker was replaced with a classically trained chef who has worked at French Laundry among other culinary epicenters. I feel his food is far better than Christian's at Atria.
  • One word: amazing. Best in Martha's and possibly many other surrounding towns
  • Wild mushroom risotto balls, asparagus & Jonah crab salad, Pimms!. Pan seared tuna, and the most amazing scallops! Great start as well!
  • Risotto balls from the bar menu are delicious!
  • Risotto balls are delicious
  • Truffle risotto balls are a must, short rib with egg also a great app. Great Sancerre : )
  • Best drink EVER: key lime pie martini
  • Burger is decent and pork tacos are great. Disagree on risotto balls-thought they were pedestrian and bland.
  • Try the Koi Pond with Don Julio Blanco Tequila.
  • Beef tartare and zucchini starters are a for sure. The scallops or tuna entree are incredible. strawberry shortcake was a perfect end to a great meal. Cocktails: pims cup or key lime martini
  • Nice vests.
  • Reliable good food here
  • Best cheeseburger. Ever.
  • In the winter they have an AMAZING pork belly appetizer!!

Nearby places

55 Main St (Summer St)