The Top 50 Cupcakes in America

From Georgetown Cupcake in Washington, D.C., to Crumbs Bake Shop in New York City and even the year-old shop around the corner, find out which cupcakery is home to the number one cupcake in America

Cupcakes from Huckleberry Bakery and Cafe in California.
Huckleberry Bakery and Café
A plate of cupcakes from Huckleberry Bakery and Cafe in California.

It’s a fact: America loves cupcakes.

These cute little confections first stole our hearts on a national level in the early 2000s thanks to a famous reference from Sex and the City. Soon, bakeries dedicated just to cupcakes — or cupcakeries, as they prefer to be called — popped up around the country, and people saw potential for greatness. Later on, when the cupcake craze exploded into a full-blown industry, there was talk of a "cupcake bubble" and everyone speculated as to when it would pop.

Click here for the Top 50 Cupcakes in America Slideshow

Clearly, they were wrong. Today, cupcakes have grown into much more than bake sale fodder. From gowns literally made of cupcake tiers to $55,000 red velvet cupcakes used to pop the question, cupcakes have become a food trend that just won’t die.

In fact, they’re kind of everywhere.

To help you tell the good from the bad (and the ugly), The Daily Meal has come up with a list of the 50 best cupcake shops in America — and the must-try flavor at each. Classics like Magnolia Bakery and Sprinkles are no surprise, but you might find that the small mom-and-pop shop just around the corner is holding its own, too.

So, how’d we do it?

The Daily Meal started with a pool of nearly 100 bakeries and cupcakeries across the country. Each seller of sweets was judged on presentation, menu, and cake-to-frosting ratio. Some bakeries received additional points for extra special features — things that made us sit up a little straighter in our chairs (or closer to our screens). After all the points were tallied, the place with the most was crowned the home of The Daily Meal’s number one cupcake in America!

First, let’s be honest, no one wants to eat something that isn’t pretty, which is why in our ranking system, presentation is worth 10 points. We are looking for polished products across the board, so attention to detail and consistently photo-ready cupcakes take the cake — er, cupcake.

Next, the menu should strike a balance for any prospective cupcake customer. Are the options overwhelming? Underwhelming? It’s important to suit a wide variety of tastes, so all-chocolate menus aren’t ideal (no matter how much any one individual appreciates it). And, while creative flavors weren’t necessary for a high score, they were certainly appreciated.

Finally, the ever-important cake-to-frosting ratio makes up the last third of the overall score. The Daily Meal conducted a taste test amongst dozens of (incredibly reluctant) volunteers and determined the optimal ratio from their input. The closer a cupcake’s actual ratio was to our ideal result, the more points awarded.

The scores from these three categories were added together for a score of up to 30. The Daily Meal pulled cupcake contenders from every state in the country, from Alaska to Wyoming, and gave even the newest start-up the same undivided attention as the giants of the industry. 

It wasn’t easy, but spending hour after hour drooling over cupcakes was a sacrifice this writer was willing to make.

You can check out the full list of contenders and their scores on the next page.

Marilyn He is a Junior Writer for the Eat/Dine section of The Daily Meal. Follow her on Twitter @Marilyn_He. 



Be a Part of the Conversation

Have something to say?
Add a comment (or see what others think).

Comments 3
3.1
Ratings220


Like this story? Get updates by email, facebook and twitter
Get daily food and wine coverage


Latest from The Daily Meal

The Daily Meal Video Network
David Guas Cooks Up Vidalia Onion Marmalade with Grilled Mini Sausages

3 Comments

tdm-35-icon.png

Sorry Daily Meal, but I have to disagree with your list. You not only left off delicious cupcakeries (Crumbs Bakeshop and Cupcake Endulgers Boutique in ATL) but your number 1 spot: Atlanta Cupcake Factory was a big disappointment this weekend. They are definitely NOT the best. Half the cupcakes we had were dry and flavorless. Only 3 out of the 7 we tried would I ever happily eat again. Check out my cupcake blog list if you want some accurate cupcakery ratings: http://asoutherngirlabroad.wordpress.com/category/the-cupcake-chronicles/

NDFoodie's picture

Obviously the writer/rater of Top 50 American Cupcakes left off the MOST important category, taste (texture/flavor). What good is Cupcake Design or Menu without taste? Although the writer alludes to composing this article entirely from internet research from her desk, I feel she should have been more forthcoming, that she didn’t actually taste all the cupcakes. One would assume that when food ratings/lists are compiled that the judge(s) would actually TASTE the items in question.
That being said, I've tried cupcakes from Sprinkles, Sweet Mandy B's, Magnolia, Baked, Angel Cups of Fargo, and countless others across the US. Needless to say, Angel Cups does not come close to the others that I've tried in terms of taste/texture/flavor. I'm extremely surprised that they beat out (or are even considered in the same league with) these world-known bakeries. It is obvious Marilyn picked the world-known favorites along with the out-of-the-way locations simply to fulfill a wide geographical representation. The true, face-to-face, taste rating of cupcakes (in combination with design, menu, cake/frosting ratio) would have been a much more meaningful article. Unfortunately, this article as rated/written from internet research is meaningless and will result in undeserved PR exposure to some establishments. In addition, for a truly well-rounded rating, the ambience of the establishment and customer service should also be included. After all, who wants to eat a great cupcake in an outdated dump?
Also, something appears to be wrong with the accompanying slide show as I’m only able to read individual reviews from 50-28 and then it stops.
As a cupcake enthusiast, I’m very disappointed.

rachelinthecity's picture

I was thinking the same thing. How do you rate cupcakes without including taste? I do agree with some of the placements (Magnolia near the bottom, Sprinkles near the top, for example), but this list just generally makes no sense. I don't understand how "menu" is even judged. And presentation counts for a third of the score? Who cares what it looks like if it tastes horrible? What an odd article.

Add a Comment

Upload a picture of yourself no larger than 3MB, please see Terms for details
CAPTCHA
Please answer this Captcha to prove you are human
Image CAPTCHA
Enter the characters shown in the image.
CAPTCHA
Please answer this Captcha to prove you are human