7) Nutter Butter from The Cookie Dunk Test Slideshow

The Cookie Dunk Test Slideshow

Slide 1 of 8
8) Mrs. Field's Chocolate Chip

Average Score: 60/100
Ideal Dunk Time: 10 to 15 seconds

The lowest-scoring of the bunch, Mrs. Field’s Chocolate Chip cookies were a letdown when dunked into 2 percent milk. The cookies were "too chewy," "didn’t absorb milk," "didn’t fit in the cup," were "trying too hard to be a fresh cookie," and "didn’t taste like the real Mrs. Field’s," according to our expert panel. Another summed it up best: "Weird."