17 Cereals That Were Too Sweet to Last

The super sugary cereals we miss the most

Quisp, Ice Cream Cones, and Nerds cereals... may they all rest in peace.
Mr. Breakfast.com/Jeffrey
Quisp, Ice Cream Cones, and Nerds cereals... may they all rest in peace.

Think back to a typical Saturday morning as a 6 year old. With cartoons on the TV and a spoon in hand, you contentedly crunch away at your sugar-loaded cereal of choice: French Toast Crunch, perhaps, or the fluorescent flakes of Nerds cereal. You slurp down the strawberry milk left in the bowl from your Strawberry Honeycomb or the rainbow-streaked Sprinkle Spangles milk remnants, and go on with your happy childhood Saturday.

Click here for 17 Cereals That Were Too Sweet To Last

Fast-forward 10 (or 20, or 30) years later. Perusing the cereal aisle, you realize how bored you are of the grown-up, healthy options that seem to have taken over. You’re overcome with nostalgia for your favorite cereal from childhood, and decide to splurge on the calories and go ahead and treat yourself to a box of that sugary goodness. 

There’s just one problem: it no longer exists.

Most popular cereals marketed to kids are household names that have been around for ages. They’re also mostly major sugar bombs — 90 percent of kids’ cereals are tested to be high in sugar. And yet, it’d be unimaginable for many of these — think Fruit Loops and Lucky Charms — to be taken off the market. After all, the average American eats 10 pounds of the stuff in a year. But year after year, beloved cereals are discontinued, leaving thousands of cereal lovers with nothing to do but reminisce about the golden days of their sugary childhood favorites.

One of these coveted cereals, Cap’n Crunch, was the subject of a recent scare that had cereal lovers everywhere panicking over the rumor that Cap’n Crunch was being "retired" as a Quaker Oats brand cereal. Noticing that the Cap’n was nowhere to be seen on the company’s main website and that there seemed to be a decline in recent promotions, fans speculated that the sugary cereal was "too unhealthy" to go on. Thankfully, Quaker put an end to the rumors and quelled our worst fears when it told AdAge, "Reports of Cap’n Crunch’s demise are greatly exaggerated."

But when it comes to over-the-top delicious cereals that happen to be high in sugar, we still live in fear that they’ll one day be taken away. Kids’ cereals are getting less sugary by the day, and efforts to combat childhood obesity, from Michelle Obama’s "Let’s Move!" campaign to the special Congress committee dedicated to halting the marketing of sugary foods to kids, promise to slow the production of these "breakfast candy" cereals. We’re all for ending childhood obesity, but it also might mean the end of a sugary cereal Golden Age. Someday soon, you could be mourning the loss of one of your current favorites.

Sometimes, you just have to forget the sugar content and take a trip down memory lane. To help you reminisce, here’s The Daily Meal’s list of 17 cereals that were just too sweet to last. 

Be a Part of the Conversation

Have something to say?
Add a comment (or see what others think).

Comments 8

Like this story? Get updates by email, facebook and twitter
Get daily food and wine coverage

Latest from The Daily Meal

The Daily Meal Video Network
Strawberry Brie Grilled Cheese



What happened to Mr. Wonderful's Surprise cereal? Yum!


My son loves Captain Crunch and made the following:




My son was crushed when he heard Captain Crunch might be taken a couple of years ago. He made the above video.

alexandergreats's picture

Government should stay out of the business of people's choices for all food items. I don't want a nanny state. As Benjamin Franklin once said "Trade your freedom for security and you will deserve neither and lose both."


It's an interesting idea you present but you are clearly not a nutritionist. First of all, you say someone 'splurges on the extra calories' when sugar has the same calories as any carbohydrate. This means your boring grown up cereal generally has the same amount of calories even if the label doesn't say sugar.

In addition, the carbohydrates in any cereal will have similar standings on the insulin index, glycemic index, and glycemic load charts, so there's really a very small functional difference if any.

The 'sugar is toxic' movement is plagued by bad science and laughable correlative studies that demonstrate nothing but that the likes of Doc Oz and Robert Lustig are only out there to make a story. Sugar is fine in moderation. The 12 grams in a serving of breakfast cereal (or even 24 in two or 36 in three!) is not going to have a measurable effect on health.

Sad times we live in

Butler Momma's picture

PLEASE bring them back!!!

Thorzine17's picture

What about Waffle Crisp? I couldn't stand the smell, but my son loves and misses it.

Thorzine17's picture

Rice Krispie Treats cereal can be found at Wal-Mart. My kids love it. (so do I)

Add a Comment

Upload a picture of yourself no larger than 3MB, please see Terms for details
Please answer this Captcha to prove you are human
Enter the characters shown in the image.
Please answer this Captcha to prove you are human