Tellers Chophouse

Row 1

605 Main St
Islip, NY 11751
(631) 277-7070
$ $ $ $
Mon–Thu: 11:30 AM–2:30 PM Fri: 11:30 AM–2:30 PM Sat: 5:00 PM–11:00 PM Sun: 3:00 PM–9:00 PM

Foursquare Tips

  • the steak and mashed potatoes are delish! (get it)
  • We reviewed Tellers Chophouse, and our critic loved the Signature Ribeye.
  • Zagat rated & vallet parking. What a great combination!!!
  • Bring the bigger wallet. Well worth it. Special occasions birthdays romantic dinners for two.
  • Probably the best steak in Suffolk county!
  • Get the Delmonico Rib Eye with the Truffle Sauce... To die for!!!
  • Duck fat French fries and beef Wellington so amazing
  • Tellers Steak House
  • I had the surf and turf and it was sublime. Lucky for me I came on their 15th anniversary and they had unlimited wine pairing with their plates.
  • The Salmon and "5 Cheese Mac" are sublime
  • Excellent service. Oysters were small bit good. A fine room to enjoy a good steak.
  • Great south bay brew- delightful!
  • Price fix for restaurant week was great! Filet mignon Wellington was awese!
  • Glass of malbec and steak salad = great lunch
  • Go on a Tuesday night for a $50, 3 course dinner with Wine Pairings! Or go on a Sunday for a Prix-fix 3 course meal
  • Get the Filet mignon Wellington!!! It's delish.
  • Sammy Hagar might be in the house.
  • Try the shrimp & lobster wonton, It's amazingly lite & not greasy. You can really taste them both. The hoy sing sauce adds a nice touch. You get a nice portion (6) as well.
  • No more half price sushi at the bar on weekdays. In fact, no more sushi at all :(
  • Tuesday Night Wine Dinner is spectacular + easy on the wallet.